Sud Shama, Wong Jonathan P, Premji Laila, Punnett Angela
Department of Paediatrics, SickKids Hospital, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2020 Jul 15;11(3):e56-e66. doi: 10.36834/cmej.69220. eCollection 2020 Jul.
It is unclear how medical students prioritize different factors when selecting a specialty. With rising under and unemployment rates a novel approach to career counselling is becoming increasingly important. A better understanding of specialty selection could lead to improved career satisfaction amongst graduates while also meeting the health care needs of Canadians.
Medical students from the University of Toronto participated in a two-phase study looking at factors impacting specialty selection. Phase I consisted of focus groups, conducted independently for each year, and Phase II was a 21-question electronic survey sent to all students.
Twenty-one students participated in the focus group phase and 95 in the survey phase. Primary themes related to career selection identified in Phase I in order of frequency included personal life factors (36), professional life factors (36), passion/interest (20), changing interests (19) and hidden curriculum (15). The survey phase had similar results with passion (83), lifestyle (79), flexibility (75), employment opportunities (60) and family (50) being ranked as the factors most important in specialty selection.
Personal factors, professional factors and passion/interest may be key themes for medical students when deciding which specialty to pursue. Targeting career counselling around these areas may be important.
医学生在选择专业时如何对不同因素进行优先级排序尚不清楚。随着失业率和未充分就业率的上升,一种新颖的职业咨询方法变得越来越重要。更好地理解专业选择可以提高毕业生的职业满意度,同时也满足加拿大人的医疗保健需求。
多伦多大学的医学生参与了一项分两阶段的研究,该研究着眼于影响专业选择的因素。第一阶段包括每年独立进行的焦点小组讨论,第二阶段是向所有学生发送的一份包含21个问题的电子调查问卷。
21名学生参与了焦点小组阶段,95名学生参与了调查阶段。在第一阶段按出现频率确定的与职业选择相关的主要主题依次为个人生活因素(36)、职业生活因素(36)、热情/兴趣(20)、兴趣变化(19)和隐性课程(15)。调查阶段的结果类似,热情(83)、生活方式(79)、灵活性(75)、就业机会(60)和家庭(50)被列为专业选择中最重要的因素。
个人因素、职业因素和热情/兴趣可能是医学生在决定追求哪个专业时的关键主题。围绕这些领域开展职业咨询可能很重要。