Department for Public Health, Health Services Research and Health Technology Assessment, UMIT TIROL-Private University for Health Sciences, Medical Informatics and Technology, 6060 Hall in Tirol, Austria.
Department of Business, University Seeburg Castle, 5201 Seekirchen am Wallersee, Austria.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Aug 27;17(17):6251. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17176251.
As past events have shown, disasters can have a tremendous impact on the affected population's health. However, research regarding the long-term impact on a systems level perspective is still scarce. In this multi-case study, we analyzed and compared the long-term impacts on the public health system of five disasters which took place in Europe: avalanche (Austria), terror attack (Spain), airplane crash (Luxembourg), cable-car tunnel fire (Austria), and a flood in Central Europe. We used a mixed-methods approach consisting of a document analysis and interviews with key stakeholders, to examine the various long-term impacts each of the disasters had on health-system performance, as well as on security and health protection. The results show manifold changes undertaken in the fields of psychosocial support, infrastructure, and contingency and preparedness planning. The holistic approach of this study shows the importance of analyzing long-term impacts from the perspective of the type (e.g., disasters associated with natural hazards) and characteristic (e.g., duration and extent) of a disaster, as well as the regional context where a disaster took place. However, the identified recurring themes demonstrate the opportunity of learning from case studies in order to customize the lessons and apply them to the own-disaster-management setting.
如以往事件所示,灾害会对受灾人群的健康造成巨大影响。然而,从系统层面研究其长期影响的相关研究仍十分匮乏。在这项多案例研究中,我们分析并比较了欧洲发生的五起灾害对公共卫生系统的长期影响:雪崩(奥地利)、恐怖袭击(西班牙)、飞机失事(卢森堡)、缆车隧道火灾(奥地利)和中欧洪水。我们采用混合方法,包括对文件的分析和对主要利益攸关方的访谈,以检查每起灾害对卫生系统绩效以及安全和健康保护的长期影响。研究结果表明,在心理社会支持、基础设施以及应急和准备规划方面进行了多种变革。这项研究的整体方法表明,从灾害类型(例如,与自然灾害相关的灾害)和特征(例如,持续时间和范围)以及灾害发生的区域背景的角度分析长期影响非常重要。然而,所确定的反复出现的主题表明,可以从案例研究中吸取经验教训,以便定制这些经验教训并将其应用于自身灾害管理环境。