在正常及特殊时期(新冠疫情期间)应对基于能力的医学课程中解剖学教育的挑战:教学框架的开发与实施
Confronting the Challenges of Anatomy Education in a Competency-Based Medical Curriculum During Normal and Unprecedented Times (COVID-19 Pandemic): Pedagogical Framework Development and Implementation.
作者信息
Naidoo Nerissa, Akhras Aya, Banerjee Yajnavalka
机构信息
College of Medicine and Health Sciences, Mohammed Bin Rashid University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
Centre of Medical Education, University of Dundee, Dundee, United Kingdom.
出版信息
JMIR Med Educ. 2020 Oct 7;6(2):e21701. doi: 10.2196/21701.
BACKGROUND
Anatomy is considered to be one of the keystones of undergraduate medical education. However, recently, there has been drastic reduction, both in gross anatomy teaching hours and its context. Additionally, a decrease in the number of trained anatomists and an increase in the costs associated with procuring human cadavers have been noted, causing a diminution of cadaveric dissections in anatomy education.
OBJECTIVE
To address these challenges, there is an ardent need for a pedagogical framework such that anatomy education can be disseminated through active learning principles, within a fixed time frame, using a small team of anatomists and a small number of cadaveric specimens (for live on-site sessions) as well as collaborative learning principles. The latter is particularly important when anatomy education is delivered through distance learning, as is the case currently during the COVID-19 pandemic.
METHODS
Here, we have blueprinted a pedagogical framework blending the instructional design models of Gagne's 9 events of instruction with Peyton's 4-step approach. The framework's applicability was validated through the delivery of anatomical concepts, using an exemplar from the structure-function course Head and Neck during the normal and COVID-19-mandated lockdown periods, employing the archetype of Frey syndrome. Preliminary evaluation of the framework was pursued using student feedback and end-of-course feedback responses. The efficiency of the framework in knowledge transfer was also appraised.
RESULTS
The blueprinted instructional plan designed to implement the pedagogical framework was successfully executed in the dissemination of anatomy education, employing a limited number of cadaveric specimens (during normal times) and a social media application (SMA)-integrated "interactome" strategy (during the COVID-19 lockdown). Students' response to the framework was positive. However, reluctance was expressed by a majority of the faculty in adopting the framework for anatomy education. To address this aspect, a strategy has been designed using Mento's 12-step change management model. The long-term benefits for any medical school to adopt the blended pedagogical framework have also been explicated by applying Bourdieu's Theory of Practice. Additionally, through the design of an SMA interactome model, the framework's applicability to the delivery of anatomy education and content during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic was realized.
CONCLUSIONS
In conclusion, the study effectively tackles some of the contemporary key challenges associated with the delivery of anatomy content in medical education during normal and unprecedented times.
背景
解剖学被认为是本科医学教育的基石之一。然而,最近大体解剖学的教学时长及其教学情境都大幅减少。此外,受过培训的解剖学家数量减少,获取人体尸体的相关成本增加,导致解剖学教育中的尸体解剖减少。
目的
为应对这些挑战,迫切需要一个教学框架,以便能通过主动学习原则,在固定时间内,利用一小队解剖学家和少量尸体标本(用于现场实操课程)以及协作学习原则来传播解剖学教育。当解剖学教育通过远程学习进行时,协作学习原则尤为重要,就像当前新冠疫情期间的情况一样。
方法
在此,我们设计了一个教学框架,将加涅的九段教学事件教学设计模型与佩顿的四步教学法相结合。通过讲授解剖学概念来验证该框架的适用性,以正常时期和新冠疫情封锁时期的头颈结构 - 功能课程中的弗雷综合征为例。利用学生反馈和课程结束时的反馈回复对该框架进行初步评估。还评估了该框架在知识传授方面的效率。
结果
为实施该教学框架而设计的教学计划在传播解剖学教育方面成功执行,在正常时期使用了有限数量的尸体标本,在新冠疫情封锁期间采用了整合社交媒体应用(SMA)的“相互作用组”策略。学生对该框架的反应是积极的。然而,大多数教员不愿意采用该框架进行解剖学教育。为解决这一问题,利用门托的十二步变革管理模型设计了一项策略。通过应用布迪厄的实践理论,阐述了任何医学院采用混合教学框架的长期益处。此外,通过设计SMA相互作用组模型,实现了该框架在当前新冠疫情期间用于解剖学教育及内容传授的适用性。
结论
总之,该研究有效应对了正常时期和前所未有的时期在医学教育中传授解剖学内容所面临的一些当代关键挑战。
相似文献
BMC Med Educ. 2019-12-27
Perspect Med Educ. 2014-12
Acta Med Port. 2017-2-27
Anat Sci Educ. 2021-1
引用本文的文献
Medicine (Baltimore). 2025-8-15
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2025-4-10
Anat Cell Biol. 2025-3-31
本文引用的文献
JMIR Med Educ. 2020-6-12
BMC Med Educ. 2019-12-27