Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Washington University in St. Louis, Campus Box 1125, One Brookings Drive, St. Louis, MO, 63130, USA.
Psychon Bull Rev. 2021 Feb;28(1):40-80. doi: 10.3758/s13423-020-01792-x.
Adult semantic memory has been traditionally conceptualized as a relatively static memory system that consists of knowledge about the world, concepts, and symbols. Considerable work in the past few decades has challenged this static view of semantic memory, and instead proposed a more fluid and flexible system that is sensitive to context, task demands, and perceptual and sensorimotor information from the environment. This paper (1) reviews traditional and modern computational models of semantic memory, within the umbrella of network (free association-based), feature (property generation norms-based), and distributional semantic (natural language corpora-based) models, (2) discusses the contribution of these models to important debates in the literature regarding knowledge representation (localist vs. distributed representations) and learning (error-free/Hebbian learning vs. error-driven/predictive learning), and (3) evaluates how modern computational models (neural network, retrieval-based, and topic models) are revisiting the traditional "static" conceptualization of semantic memory and tackling important challenges in semantic modeling such as addressing temporal, contextual, and attentional influences, as well as incorporating grounding and compositionality into semantic representations. The review also identifies new challenges regarding the abundance and availability of data, the generalization of semantic models to other languages, and the role of social interaction and collaboration in language learning and development. The concluding section advocates the need for integrating representational accounts of semantic memory with process-based accounts of cognitive behavior, as well as the need for explicit comparisons of computational models to human baselines in semantic tasks to adequately assess their psychological plausibility as models of human semantic memory.
成人语义记忆传统上被概念化为一个相对静态的记忆系统,它由关于世界、概念和符号的知识组成。在过去几十年中,大量的工作挑战了这种对语义记忆的静态观点,而是提出了一个更具流动性和灵活性的系统,该系统对环境中的上下文、任务需求以及感知和感觉运动信息敏感。本文(1)回顾了语义记忆的传统和现代计算模型,这些模型包括网络(基于自由联想)、特征(基于属性生成规范)和分布式语义(基于自然语言语料库)模型,(2)讨论了这些模型对文献中关于知识表示(局部与分布式表示)和学习(无错误/赫布学习与错误驱动/预测学习)的重要争论的贡献,(3)评估了现代计算模型(神经网络、基于检索的模型和主题模型)如何重新审视语义记忆的传统“静态”概念,并解决语义建模中的重要挑战,例如解决时间、上下文和注意力的影响,以及将基础和组合性纳入语义表示。综述还确定了关于数据的丰富性和可用性、语义模型向其他语言的推广以及社会互动和协作在语言学习和发展中的作用等新挑战。结论部分主张需要将语义记忆的表示性解释与认知行为的基于过程的解释相结合,以及需要对语义任务中的计算模型与人类基准进行明确比较,以充分评估其作为人类语义记忆模型的心理合理性。