Campiglio Laura, Priori Alberto
Department of Health Sciences, "Aldo Ravelli" Center for Experimental Brain Therapeutics and Clinical Neurology Unit, University of Milan, Italy, San Paolo University Hospital, ASST Santi Paolo e Carlo, Milan, Italy.
PLoS One. 2020 Sep 11;15(9):e0238159. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0238159. eCollection 2020.
COVID-19 is a pandemic disease and questions rise about the coronavirus 2 (Sars-CoV-2) effect on nervous system. This involvement could help explaining the pathogenesis of this condition and lead to novel therapeutic approaches.
To assess the occurrence of neurological symptoms in COVID-19 patients during the Italian pandemic outbreak, as reported by physicians.
In the early days of pandemic emergence we developed an online survey open to all Italian clinicians involved in the diagnosis and management of COVID-19 patients. The survey was structured in three sections, with nine different items concerning the presence of different specific clinical abnormalities. Each item was graded from "absent" to "severe" in a 4-point Likert's scale.
Likert's scale data were analyzed by studying the distribution of responses by using medians and bar charts-relative frequencies. Also, in order to analyze differences in symptoms findings depending on the group of specialty, Likert's scale data were combined into two nominal categories ("absent"/"low" and "moderate"/"high"/") and a contingency table chi-square test was used.
126 physicians of 9 different medical specialties, from 10 regions of Italy, filled the online survey. The results show that 87.3% of practitioners reported neurological symptoms. In most cases these were mild and non-specific, but they were severe in a minority of patients. The most common symptoms observed were headache, myalgia and taste and smell abnormalities. Whilst there was no difference between neurologists and non-neurologists, we found that experienced clinicians (defined as clinicians that evaluated more than 30 patients) reported neurological symptoms more frequently than non-expert.
Neurological symptoms have frequently been ported during the Italian COVID-19 pandemic, and thus should be monitored for all affected patients. Whilst some of the disturbances reported may be non-specific and common to other infectious diseases, smell and taste abnormalities might indicate nervous system as entry door for SARS-CoV-2 virus. This interpretation should promote research trials to avoid nervous system involvement.
新型冠状病毒肺炎(COVID-19)是一种大流行性疾病,关于严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)对神经系统的影响也引发了诸多问题。这种关联有助于解释该疾病的发病机制,并带来新的治疗方法。
评估意大利疫情爆发期间医生报告的COVID-19患者神经症状的发生率。
在疫情出现的早期,我们开展了一项在线调查,面向所有参与COVID-19患者诊断和管理的意大利临床医生。该调查分为三个部分,包含九个关于不同特定临床异常情况的不同项目。每个项目按照李克特四点量表从“无”到“严重”进行分级。
通过使用中位数和柱状图相对频率研究回答分布情况,对李克特量表数据进行分析。此外,为了分析不同专业组症状表现的差异,将李克特量表数据合并为两个名义类别(“无”/“低”和“中度”/“高度”),并使用列联表卡方检验。
来自意大利10个地区的9个不同医学专业的126名医生填写了在线调查。结果显示,87.3%的从业者报告了神经症状。在大多数情况下,这些症状较轻且不具有特异性,但少数患者症状严重。观察到的最常见症状是头痛、肌痛以及味觉和嗅觉异常。虽然神经科医生和非神经科医生之间没有差异,但我们发现经验丰富的临床医生(定义为评估超过30名患者的临床医生)比非专家更频繁地报告神经症状。
在意大利COVID-19疫情期间,经常报告有神经症状,因此应对所有受影响患者进行监测。虽然报告的一些紊乱可能不具有特异性且在其他传染病中常见,但嗅觉和味觉异常可能表明神经系统是SARS-CoV-2病毒的侵入门户。这种解释应推动研究试验以避免神经系统受累。