Nossal Institute for Global Health, Melbourne School of Population and Global Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Department of Psychiatry, Voluntary Health Services, Chennai, India.
PLoS One. 2020 Sep 21;15(9):e0239280. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0239280. eCollection 2020.
Suicide rates in India are among the highest in the world, equating to over 200,000 suicide deaths annually. Crime reports of suicide incidents routinely feature in the Indian mass media, with minimal coverage of suicide as a broader public health issue. To supplement our recently published content analysis study, we undertook qualitative interviews to examine media professionals' perspectives and experiences in relation to media reporting of suicide-related news in India.
In 2017-18, semi-structured qualitative interviews with twenty-eight print media and television media professionals with experience reporting on suicide-related news were undertaken across north (New Delhi and Chandigarh) and south (Chennai) India. A semi-structured interview guide was designed to initiate discussions around; 1) perspectives on why suicide incidents are regularly reported on by mass media in India, 2) a description of experiences and processes of covering suicide incidents on the crime beat; and 3) perspectives on the emergence of health reporter coverage of suicide. Interviews were digitally audio-recorded and transcribed. A deductive and inductive thematic analytic approach was used, supported by the use of NVivo.
Suicides were typically seen as being highly newsworthy and of interest to the audience, particularly the suicides of high-status people and those who somewhat matched the middle-class profile of the core audience. Socio-cultural factors played a major role in determining the newsworthiness of a particular incident. The capacity to link a suicide incident to compelling social narratives, potentially detrimental social/policy issues, and placing the suicide as a form of protest/martyrdom increased newsworthiness. Reporters on the crime beat worked in close partnership with police to produce routine and simplified incident report-style coverage of suicide incidents, with the process influenced by: informal police contacts supporting the crime beat, the speed of breaking news, extremely tight word limits and a deeply fraught engagement with bereaved family members. It was articulated that a public health and/or mental health framing of suicide was an emerging perspective, which sought to focus more on broader trends and suicide prevention programs rather than individual incidents. Important challenges were identified around the complexity of adopting a mental health framing of suicide, given the perceived pervasive influence of socioeconomic and cultural issues (rather than individual psychopathology) on suicide in India.
Our findings delve into the complexity of reporting on suicide in India and can be used to support constructive partnerships between media professionals and suicide prevention experts in India. Policymakers need to acknowledge the socio-cultural context of suicide reporting in India when adapting international guidelines for the Indian media.
印度的自杀率位居世界前列,每年有超过 20 万人自杀。犯罪报告中经常出现自杀事件,而印度大众媒体对自杀作为一个更广泛的公共卫生问题的报道却很少。为了补充我们最近发表的内容分析研究,我们进行了定性访谈,以研究媒体专业人士对印度媒体报道自杀相关新闻的看法和经验。
2017-18 年,在印度北部(新德里和昌迪加尔)和南部(钦奈)对 28 名有报道自杀相关新闻经验的平面媒体和电视媒体专业人士进行了半结构化定性访谈。设计了一份半结构化访谈指南,以启动以下讨论:1)为什么印度大众媒体经常报道自杀事件的观点;2)报道犯罪新闻中涉及自杀事件的经验和过程的描述;3)健康记者报道自杀的观点。访谈进行了数字音频记录和转录。采用了演绎和归纳主题分析方法,并使用了 NVivo 支持。
自杀通常被视为极具新闻价值,并且对观众有很大的吸引力,尤其是那些高地位人士和那些与核心观众的中产阶级形象有些匹配的人的自杀。社会文化因素在决定某一事件的新闻价值方面起着重要作用。将自杀事件与引人注目的社会叙事、潜在的有害社会/政策问题联系起来,并将自杀视为一种抗议/殉难形式,会增加新闻价值。犯罪新闻记者与警方密切合作,以制作例行的、简化的自杀事件报道风格,这一过程受到以下因素的影响:支持犯罪新闻的非正式警察联系、突发新闻的速度、非常严格的字数限制以及与悲痛欲绝的家属的深度紧张接触。有人指出,自杀的公共卫生和/或心理健康框架是一个新兴的观点,它试图更关注更广泛的趋势和自杀预防计划,而不是个别事件。在印度,自杀受到社会经济和文化问题(而不是个体心理病理学)的普遍影响,因此在采用自杀的心理健康框架方面存在重要挑战。
我们的研究结果深入探讨了印度报道自杀事件的复杂性,并可用于支持印度媒体专业人士与自杀预防专家之间建立建设性的伙伴关系。政策制定者在调整国际指南以适应印度媒体时,需要认识到印度自杀报道的社会文化背景。