Chriki Sghaier, Ellies-Oury Marie-Pierre, Fournier Dominique, Liu Jingjing, Hocquette Jean-François
ISARA, Agroecology and Environment Unit, Lyon, France.
Bordeaux Sciences Agro, Gradignan, France.
Front Psychol. 2020 Aug 25;11:1845. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01845. eCollection 2020.
Cultured meat is presented by its advocates as a good alternative for consumers who want to be more ethically minded but who do not wish to change their diet. This novel food has become an emerging topic in both the scientific field and the press media. From a bibliometric analysis of scientific publications and on a sociometric analysis of the mainstream press, the aim of this study was to identify potential differences between the scientific view and the public perception. This research analyzed the publications indexed by SCI-EXPANDED in the Web of Science Core Collection database owned by Clarivate Analytics, for scientific literature analysis, and indexed by the Factiva database, for the press media. A total of 327 scientific publications were analyzed according to year of publication and country and institution of origin, also including coauthorships, co-citations, and scientific fields' and journals' networks. A knowledge mapping using VOSviewer was used to study the literature in the field. Based on Factiva, 12,900 press articles dealing with artificial meat, mainly in English, have been found through public databases. The main conclusion is that cultured meat is mainly developing in the USA and the UK, with other countries, such as China, observing the trend for potential future applications. Scientific articles seemed initially to focus mainly on technical aspects of artificial meat and more recently on health value, consumer's acceptance, and sustainability. However, the potential environment-friendly effects of this novel food are more and more studied or described in scientific or press articles.
人造肉的倡导者认为,对于那些希望在道德上更有觉悟但又不想改变饮食习惯的消费者来说,人造肉是一个不错的选择。这种新型食品已成为科学领域和新闻媒体中一个新兴的话题。通过对科学出版物的文献计量分析以及对主流媒体的社会计量分析,本研究旨在找出科学观点与公众认知之间的潜在差异。本研究分析了科睿唯安旗下Web of Science核心合集数据库中SCI-EXPANDED索引的出版物用于科学文献分析,以及Factiva数据库索引的出版物用于新闻媒体分析。根据出版年份、原产国和机构对总共327篇科学出版物进行了分析,还包括共同作者、共同引用以及科学领域和期刊网络。使用VOSviewer进行知识图谱分析来研究该领域的文献。基于Factiva,通过公共数据库发现了12900篇主要用英语撰写的关于人造肉的新闻文章。主要结论是,人造肉主要在美国和英国发展,其他国家如中国则在观察其未来潜在应用的趋势。科学文章最初似乎主要关注人造肉的技术方面,最近则更多地关注健康价值、消费者接受度和可持续性。然而,这种新型食品潜在的环保效果在科学或新闻文章中得到了越来越多的研究或描述。