Norden Justin G, Wang Jonathan X, Desai Sumbul A, Cheung Lauren
Department of Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, USA.
Digit Health. 2020 Sep 17;6:2055207620958528. doi: 10.1177/2055207620958528. eCollection 2020 Jan-Dec.
Telemedicine practice has been shown to vary from clinical guidelines. Variations in practice patterns may be caused by disruptions in the continuity of care between traditional and telemedicine providers. This study compares virtual and in-person visits in Stanford's ClickWell Care (CWC) - where patients see the same provider for both visit modalities.
Clinical data for two years of patient encounters at CWC from January 2015-2017 (5772 visits) were obtained through Stanford STRIDE. For the 20 most common visit categories, including 17 specific diagnoses, we compared the frequency of prescriptions, labs, procedures, and images ordered, as well as rates of repeat visits.
For the 17 specific diagnoses, there are no differences in labs ordered. Two diagnoses show differences in images ordered, and four differences in prescriptions. Overall, there are more labs (0.16 virtual, 0.33 in-person p < 0.0001) and images ordered (0.07 virtual, 0.16 in-person, p < 0.0001) for in-person visits - due mainly to general medical exam visits. Repeat visits were more likely after in-person visits (19% virtual, 38% in-person, p < 0.0001), 10 out of 17 specific diagnoses showed differences in visit frequency between visit modalities. Visits for both anxiety (5.3x, p < 0.0001) and depression (5.1x, p < 0.0001) were much more frequent in the virtual setting.
Prescriptions, labs, and images ordered were similar between in-person and virtual visits for most diagnoses. Overall however, for in-person visits we find increased orders for labs and images, primarily from general medical exams. Finally, for anxiety and depression patients show clear preferences for virtual visits.
远程医疗实践已被证明与临床指南存在差异。实践模式的差异可能是由传统医疗服务提供者和远程医疗服务提供者之间护理连续性的中断所导致。本研究比较了斯坦福大学ClickWell Care(CWC)中的虚拟就诊和面对面就诊情况,在CWC中患者在两种就诊方式下看的是同一位医疗服务提供者。
通过斯坦福大学的STRIDE获取了2015年1月至2017年CWC两年间患者就诊的临床数据(5772次就诊)。对于20种最常见的就诊类别,包括17种具体诊断,我们比较了所开具处方、实验室检查、诊疗程序和影像检查的频率,以及复诊率。
对于17种具体诊断,所开具的实验室检查没有差异。两种诊断在影像检查方面存在差异,四种诊断在处方方面存在差异。总体而言,面对面就诊所开具的实验室检查(虚拟就诊为0.16项,面对面就诊为0.33项,p<0.0001)和影像检查(虚拟就诊为0.07项,面对面就诊为0.16项,p<0.0001)更多,这主要是由于普通医学检查就诊。面对面就诊后复诊的可能性更大(虚拟就诊为19%,面对面就诊为38%,p<0.0001),17种具体诊断中有10种在不同就诊方式下的就诊频率存在差异。焦虑症(5.3倍,p<0.0001)和抑郁症(5.1倍,p<0.0001)的就诊在虚拟就诊环境中更为频繁。
对于大多数诊断,面对面就诊和虚拟就诊所开具的处方、实验室检查和影像检查相似。然而总体而言,对于面对面就诊,我们发现实验室检查和影像检查的开具增加,主要来自普通医学检查。最后,对于焦虑症和抑郁症患者,他们明显更喜欢虚拟就诊。