Department of Leadership and Military Pedagogy, National Defence University, Helsinki, Finland
Training Division, Defence Command, Helsinki, Finland.
BMJ Mil Health. 2022 Oct;168(5):337-342. doi: 10.1136/bmjmilitary-2020-001513. Epub 2020 Sep 30.
Military training programmes are often similar for male and female recruits despite sex differences in physical performance that may influence training adaptations during military service. The present study aimed to compare changes in physical fitness and anthropometrics between Finnish female and male recruits during military service.
A total of 234 690 male and 3549 female recruits participated in fitness tests at the beginning and end of military service between 2005 and 2015. Anthropometric measurements were body mass, height, body mass index (BMI) and waist circumference (WC). Fitness tests consisted 12 min running, standing long jump, and sit-ups and push-ups.
No changes were observed in anthropometrics, while both sexes improved most of the fitness test results. After adjustment for service time, branch, age, initial fitness test results, BMI and WC, improvement in running test performance was 158 m (95% CI 142 to 173, p≤0.001) greater in male than female recruits. Similarly, improvements were larger in male recruits for push-ups (5 reps/min, 95% CI 5 to 6, p≤0.001), sit-ups (2 reps/min, 95% CI 2 to 3, p≤0.001) and standing long jump (12 cm, 95% CI 11 to 13, p≤0.001) when compared with women.
The study revealed sex differences in adaptations to the standardised military training. Both male and female recruits improved their physical fitness, but smaller gains were observed in women using the same training programme. The mechanisms explaining sex differences in adaptations to military training, and whether tailored training programmes are needed specifically for female recruits to reduce sex differences during military service, warrants further studies.
尽管男性和女性在身体表现方面存在差异,这可能会影响他们在兵役期间的训练适应,但军事训练计划通常对男女新兵是相似的。本研究旨在比较芬兰男女新兵在兵役期间的身体素质和人体测量学的变化。
2005 年至 2015 年间,共有 234690 名男性和 3549 名女性新兵参加了兵役开始和结束时的体能测试。人体测量学测量包括体重、身高、体重指数(BMI)和腰围(WC)。体能测试包括 12 分钟跑步、立定跳远、仰卧起坐和俯卧撑。
在入伍期间,男女新兵的人体测量学指标均无变化,但男女新兵的大多数体能测试结果都有所提高。在调整服役时间、兵种、年龄、初始体能测试结果、BMI 和 WC 后,男性新兵的跑步测试成绩提高了 158 米(95%CI 142 至 173,p≤0.001),明显优于女性新兵。同样,男性新兵在俯卧撑(5 次/分钟,95%CI 5 至 6,p≤0.001)、仰卧起坐(2 次/分钟,95%CI 2 至 3,p≤0.001)和立定跳远(12 厘米,95%CI 11 至 13,p≤0.001)方面的进步也明显大于女性新兵。
该研究揭示了适应标准化军事训练的性别差异。男性和女性新兵都提高了他们的身体素质,但女性新兵在使用相同的训练计划时,身体素质的提高幅度较小。解释适应军事训练的性别差异的机制,以及是否需要为女性新兵专门制定特定的训练计划以减少兵役期间的性别差异,需要进一步的研究。