McFarlane Steven, Cipolletti Perez Heather, Weissglass Christine
Department of Philosophy, University of Minnesota at Morris, Morris, MN, United States.
Department of Philosophy and Religion, Broward College, Fort Lauderdale, FL, United States.
Front Psychol. 2020 Sep 3;11:549083. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.549083. eCollection 2020.
The majority of research on learning a non-native language has focused on the personal benefits of being bilingual or multilingual. In this paper, we focus on the potential positive effect of in a non-native language. Our approach is inspired by recent experimental research suggesting that actively thinking in a non-native language leads to improved reasoning and decision-making, which is known as the foreign-language effect (FLE). We examine the possibility that one could choose to think in a non-native language in order to reap these potential benefits. Integrating this research with research in positive psychology, we explain how doing so might be understood as a type of "nudge," or intervention that one could use to increase their chances of making autonomous decisions reflecting their own best interest. Nudges have been associated with improved outcomes with respect to many aspects of our lives - for instance sticking to goals, saving money, exercising more frequently, maintaining a healthy diet. It may be that bilinguals can assume an active role in increasing their happiness or well-being by making better decisions through strategic implementation of a non-native language in decision-making contexts. We also discuss the ethics of using the FLE as a nudge when it has beneficial consequences, as there are instances when doing so could be beneficial with respect to public policy as well. For instance, it has been shown that people are less averse to sustainable farming and eating practices (e.g., eating insects) when actively thinking in a non-native language. After reviewing the current research on the FLE, we suggest that further research needs to be done because actively thinking in a non-native language seems to function beneficially in some circumstances but may pose cognitive disadvantages in others.
大多数关于学习非母语的研究都集中在双语或多语言带来的个人益处上。在本文中,我们关注的是用非母语思考的潜在积极影响。我们的方法受到近期实验研究的启发,该研究表明用非母语进行积极思考会带来推理和决策能力的提升,这就是所谓的外语效应(FLE)。我们探讨了人们是否可以选择用非母语思考以获取这些潜在益处的可能性。将这项研究与积极心理学的研究相结合,我们解释了这样做如何可以被理解为一种“助推”,即一种人们可以用来增加做出符合自身最佳利益的自主决策机会的干预方式。助推在我们生活的许多方面都与改善结果相关——例如坚持目标、存钱、更频繁地锻炼、保持健康饮食。双语者或许可以通过在决策情境中战略性地运用非母语做出更好的决策,从而在提升自身幸福感方面发挥积极作用。我们还讨论了在利用外语效应带来有益结果时将其作为一种助推手段的伦理问题,因为在某些情况下这样做在公共政策方面也可能是有益的。例如,研究表明,当人们用非母语积极思考时,他们对可持续农业和饮食方式(如食用昆虫)的抵触情绪会降低。在回顾了当前关于外语效应的研究后,我们认为还需要进一步开展研究,因为用非母语进行积极思考在某些情况下似乎能发挥有益作用,但在其他情况下可能会带来认知劣势。