Lobstein Tim, Neveux Margot, Landon Jane
Policy Department World Obesity Federation London UK.
The Boden Institute, Charles Perkins Centre The University of Sydney Sydney New South Wales Australia.
Obes Sci Pract. 2020 Jul 10;6(5):562-583. doi: 10.1002/osp4.423. eCollection 2020 Oct.
Obesity prevention policies are a priority for many governments and intergovernmental agencies. Policy makers not only use systematic reviews of effectiveness but also consider contextual issues including cost and cost-effectiveness, equity, rights, acceptability and feasibility. To support their work, the present narrative review examines three contextual issues (costs, equity and acceptability) in relation to three policies for obesity prevention: sweetened beverage taxes, front-of-pack nutrition labelling and restrictions on advertising to children. Literature searches led to over 1100 documents, of which 125 informed the present review. Beverage taxes were found likely to be highly cost-effective, moderately favourable for health equity, supported by the public (depending on the use of revenues) and by health professionals and civil society groups and opposed by commercial interests. Depending on the design, front-of-pack nutritional labelling is likely to be highly cost-effective, moderately favourable for health equity, supported by the public, health professionals and civil society groups, and opposed by commercial interests. Restrictions on child-directed advertising are likely to be highly cost-effective in the longer term, moderately favourable for health equity, supported by the public, health professionals and civil society groups and opposed by commercial interests (unless voluntary). The evidence base needs strengthening, but the authors find that all three policies merit consideration by governmental authorities, and should be implemented to reduce obesity risk.
预防肥胖政策是许多政府和政府间机构的优先事项。政策制定者不仅会参考有效性的系统评价,还会考虑背景问题,包括成本和成本效益、公平性、权利、可接受性和可行性。为支持他们的工作,本叙述性综述考察了与三项预防肥胖政策相关的三个背景问题(成本、公平性和可接受性):含糖饮料税、食品包装正面营养标签以及对儿童广告的限制。文献检索得到了1100多篇文献,其中125篇为本综述提供了信息。研究发现,饮料税可能具有很高的成本效益,对健康公平性有一定的促进作用,得到公众(取决于税收用途)、卫生专业人员和民间社会团体的支持,但遭到商业利益集团的反对。根据设计不同,食品包装正面营养标签可能具有很高的成本效益,对健康公平性有一定的促进作用,得到公众、卫生专业人员和民间社会团体的支持,但遭到商业利益集团的反对。从长远来看,对儿童定向广告的限制可能具有很高的成本效益,对健康公平性有一定的促进作用,得到公众、卫生专业人员和民间社会团体的支持,但遭到商业利益集团的反对(除非是自愿性的)。证据基础需要加强,但作者认为这三项政策都值得政府当局考虑,并应予以实施以降低肥胖风险。