McInerney Joseph D, Dougherty Michael J
Biological Sciences Curriculum Study National Coalition for Health Professional Education in Genetics American Society of Human Genetics Lutherville MD USA.
Department of Pediatrics University of Colorado School of Medicine Aurora CO USA.
FASEB Bioadv. 2020 Aug 25;2(10):587-595. doi: 10.1096/fba.2020-00054. eCollection 2020 Oct.
The perversion of science in the interest of ideology and greed is not a new phenomenon, but a public that is largely scientifically illiterate now is besieged by "alternative facts" and well-designed efforts to discredit legitimate science on topics ranging from vaccines to climate change. Here, we examine three topics rooted in biology and biomedicine-creationism, harms from tobacco, and opioid addiction-to show that those purveying misinformation employ a consistent pattern of intellectual dishonesty to delegitimize science that challenges their ideological positions. Individual scientists and the scientific community at large should confront and counter these attacks on the intellectual integrity that is at the heart of the scientific enterprise.
为了意识形态和贪婪而扭曲科学并非新现象,但如今很大程度上缺乏科学素养的公众正被“另类事实”以及精心策划的抹黑合法科学的行为所包围,这些话题涵盖从疫苗到气候变化等诸多领域。在此,我们审视三个植根于生物学和生物医学的主题——神创论、烟草危害和阿片类药物成瘾——以表明那些传播错误信息的人采用了一种一致的不诚实智力模式,以使挑战他们意识形态立场的科学失去合法性。个别科学家和整个科学界应该直面并反击这些对科学事业核心的知识完整性的攻击。