Public Health Department, Universidad Industrial de Santander, Bucaramanga, Colombia.
Public Health Department, Universidad del Norte, Barranquilla, Colombia.
Int J Health Serv. 2021 Jan;51(1):31-36. doi: 10.1177/0020731420968446. Epub 2020 Oct 25.
Currently, the fast spread of COVID-19 is the cause of a sanitary emergency in Brazil. This situation is largely due to President Bolsonaro's denial and the uncoordinated actions between the federal and local governments. In addition, the Brazilian government has reported that it would change its method of sharing information about the pandemic. On June 6, 2020, the presentation of accumulated cases and deaths was stopped, and the Supreme Court of Brazil determined that the federal government should continue to consolidate and disseminate the accumulated figures of cases and deaths. However, doubt about the transparency of the data remained. We used data reported by the government from Situation Reports 38-209 of the World Health Organization to assess the Benford's law fulfillment as an indicator of data quality. This rapid evaluation of data quality during the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil suggests that the Brazilian public health surveillance system had an acceptable performance at the beginning of the epidemic. Since the end of June, the quality of cumulative death data began to decrease and remains in that condition as of August 2020. A similar situation has existed since August, with the data of accumulated new cases.
目前,COVID-19 的快速传播是巴西卫生紧急情况的原因。这种情况在很大程度上是由于总统博索纳罗的否认以及联邦政府和地方政府之间行动不协调造成的。此外,巴西政府报告称将改变其有关大流行病信息的共享方式。2020 年 6 月 6 日,停止了累计病例和死亡人数的报告,巴西最高法院裁定联邦政府应继续整合和传播病例和死亡人数的累计数据。然而,人们对数据的透明度仍存在疑虑。我们使用政府从世界卫生组织第 38-209 号情况报告中报告的数据,评估了本福德定律的遵守情况作为数据质量的指标。这项对巴西正在进行的 COVID-19 大流行期间数据质量的快速评估表明,巴西公共卫生监测系统在疫情开始时表现良好。自 6 月底以来,累积死亡数据的质量开始下降,截至 2020 年 8 月仍保持这种状态。自 8 月以来,累积新病例数据一直存在类似情况。