School of Tourism & Health, Zhejiang A&F University, Hangzhou 311300, China.
Department of Educational Sciences and Teacher Education, University of Oulu, FI-90014 Oulu, Finland.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Oct 27;17(21):7876. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17217876.
In this qualitative study, we aim to identify suitable pedagogical approaches to teaching and learning green chemistry among college students and preservice teachers by examining the teaching methods that have been used to promote green chemistry education (GCE) and how these methods have supported green chemistry learning (GCL). We found 45 articles published in peer-reviewed scientific journals since 2000 that specifically described teaching methods for GCE. The content of the articles was analyzed based on the categories of the teaching methods used and the revised version of Bloom's taxonomy. Among the selected articles, collaborative and interdisciplinary learning, and problem-based learning were utilized in 38 and 35 articles, respectively. These were the most frequently used teaching methods, alongside a general combination of multiple teaching methods and teacher presentations. Developing collaborative and interdisciplinary learning skills, techniques for increasing environmental awareness, problem-centered learning skills, and systems thinking skills featuring the teaching methods were seen to promote GCL in 44, 40, 34, and 29 articles, respectively. The results showed that the integration of green chemistry teaching (GCT), e.g., with sustainable education, promoted GCL by fostering environmental consciousness and behavioral change and cognitive processes in a sustainable direction.
在这项定性研究中,我们旨在通过考察已用于促进绿色化学教育(GCE)的教学方法以及这些方法如何支持绿色化学学习(GCL),来确定适合大学生和职前教师的绿色化学教学方法。我们找到了自 2000 年以来在同行评议的科学期刊上发表的 45 篇专门描述 GCE 教学方法的文章。根据所使用的教学方法类别和修订版的布鲁姆分类法对文章的内容进行了分析。在所选择的文章中,分别有 38 篇和 35 篇文章使用了合作学习和跨学科学习,这是最常用的教学方法,此外还有多种教学方法和教师演示的一般组合。在 44、40、34 和 29 篇文章中,分别看到了发展合作和跨学科学习技能、提高环境意识的技术、以问题为中心的学习技能和系统思维技能的教学方法促进了 GCL。结果表明,绿色化学教学(GCT)的整合,例如与可持续教育的整合,通过促进环境意识和行为改变以及可持续方向的认知过程,促进了 GCL。