Guha Chandana, Lopez-Vargas P, Ju Angela, Gutman Talia, Scholes-Robertson Nicole Jane, Baumgart Amanda, Wong Germaine, Craig Jonathan, Usherwood Tim, Reid Sharon, Cullen Vanessa, Howell Martin, Khalid Rabia, Teixeira-Pinto Armando, Wyburn Kate, Sen Shaundeep, Smolonogov Tanya, Lee Vincent W, Rangan Gopala K, Matus Gonzales Andrea, Tong Allison
Sydney School of Public Health, The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
Centre for Kidney Research, The Children's Hospital, Westmead, New South Wales, Australia.
BMJ Open. 2020 Nov 5;10(11):e040617. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-040617.
Patients with early chronic kidney disease (CKD) face challenges in accessing healthcare, including delays in diagnosis, fragmented speciality care and lack of tailored education and psychosocial support. Patient navigator programmes have the potential to improve the process of care and outcomes. The objective of this study is to describe the experiences of patients on communication, access of care and self-management and their perspectives on patient navigator programmes in early CKD.
DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: We convened a workshop in Australia with 19 patients with CKD (all stages including CKD Stage 1 to 5 not on dialysis, 5D (dialysis), and 5T (transplant)) and five caregivers. All of them were over 18 years and English-speaking. Transcripts from the workshop were analysed thematically.
Four themes that captured discussions were: lost in the ambiguity of symptoms and management, battling roadblocks while accessing care, emotionally isolated after diagnosis and re-establishing lifestyle and forward planning. Five themes that focussed on patient navigator programmes were: trust and credibility, respecting patient choices and readiness to accept the programme, using accessible language to promote the programme, offering multiple ways to engage and communicate and maintaining confidentiality and privacy. Of the 17 features identified as important for a patient navigator programme, the top five were delivery of education, psychosocial support, lifestyle modification, communication and decision-making support and facilitating care.
Patient navigator services can address gaps in services around health literacy, communication, psychosocial support and coordination across multiple healthcare settings. In comparison to the existing navigator programmes, and other services that are aimed at addressing these gaps, credible, accessible and flexible patient navigator programmes for patients with early CKD, that support education, decision-making, access to care and self-management designed in partnership with patients, may be more acceptable to patients.
早期慢性肾脏病(CKD)患者在获得医疗保健方面面临挑战,包括诊断延迟、专科护理碎片化以及缺乏针对性的教育和心理社会支持。患者导航计划有可能改善护理过程和结果。本研究的目的是描述早期CKD患者在沟通、获得护理和自我管理方面的经历,以及他们对患者导航计划的看法。
设计、地点与参与者:我们在澳大利亚举办了一次研讨会,有19名CKD患者(包括CKD 1至5期未透析患者、5D(透析)和5T(移植)患者)以及5名护理人员参加。他们均年满18岁且讲英语。对研讨会的文字记录进行了主题分析。
涵盖讨论内容的四个主题是:在症状和管理的模糊性中迷失、获得护理时遭遇障碍、诊断后情感孤立以及重新建立生活方式和前瞻性规划。关注患者导航计划的五个主题是:信任与可信度、尊重患者选择并愿意接受该计划、使用通俗易懂的语言宣传该计划、提供多种参与和沟通方式以及保持保密性和隐私性。在确定对患者导航计划重要性的17个特征中,排名前五的是提供教育、心理社会支持、生活方式改变、沟通和决策支持以及促进护理。
患者导航服务可以弥补围绕健康素养、沟通、心理社会支持以及跨多个医疗环境协调方面的服务差距。与现有的导航计划以及旨在弥补这些差距的其他服务相比,为早期CKD患者设计的、与患者合作开展的、支持教育、决策、获得护理和自我管理的、可信、可及且灵活的患者导航计划可能更容易被患者接受。