University of Pittsburgh Comprehensive Epilepsy Center (UPCEC), Department of Neurology, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, U.S.A.; and.
Magnetoencephalography Laboratory, Cleveland Clinic Epilepsy Center, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
J Clin Neurophysiol. 2020 Nov;37(6):599-605. doi: 10.1097/WNP.0000000000000716.
The purported underutilization of magnetoencephalography (MEG) among the USA epilepsy centers has never been studied, and any evidence-based understanding of its magnitude is lacking.
Two hundred twenty-five National Association of Epilepsy Centers centers (2016) were invited to participate anonymously in a 13-question web-based survey of clinical practice focused on MEG use.
On average, centers (N = 70; 61 of which were level 4) reported <6 epileptologists, >7 dedicated epilepsy monitoring unit beds, 206 phase 1 studies, 15 phase 2 studies, 10 direct resections, and 9 indirect resections; 27% owned MEG. On average, 11.2 MEGs per year were ordered for epilepsy localization and 7.6 for any presurgical mapping modalities. Wada test aka the intracarotid sodium amobarbital procedure (ISAP) (43%) and functional MRI (29%) were preferred over MEG (4%) for language mapping. The number of epileptologists and the number of epilepsy monitoring unit beds correlated positively with the most clinical volumes. The centers who own a MEG had surgical volumes significantly higher than those without. The number and complexity of patients as well as the proximity of a MEG were perceived as significant contributors/obstacles to increased MEG use.
Only the centers with larger surgical volumes incorporate MEG regularly in presurgical evaluation of patients with drug-resistant epilepsy. A reversal of the pervasive underutilization of epilepsy surgery can benefit from MEG, but this requires a sustained concerted promotion by the epilepsy and MEG communities.
美国癫痫中心磁源成像(MEG)利用率低的说法从未得到过研究,因此缺乏对其规模的任何循证理解。
225 家国家癫痫中心(2016 年)受邀匿名参与一项针对 MEG 使用的临床实践的 13 个问题的网络调查。
平均而言,中心(N=70;其中 61 家为 4 级)报告了<6 名癫痫专家、>7 张专门的癫痫监测单元病床、206 项 1 期研究、15 项 2 期研究、10 例直接切除和 9 例间接切除;27%的中心拥有 MEG。平均每年有 11.2 例 MEG 用于癫痫定位,7.6 例用于任何术前映射模式。Wada 测试(又名颈内动脉苯巴比妥钠试验(ISAP))(43%)和功能磁共振成像(29%)优先于 MEG(4%)用于语言映射。癫痫专家人数和癫痫监测单元病床数量与最高临床量呈正相关。拥有 MEG 的中心的手术量明显高于没有 MEG 的中心。患者数量和复杂性以及 MEG 的接近程度被认为是增加 MEG 使用的重要因素/障碍。
只有那些手术量较大的中心才会在药物难治性癫痫患者的术前评估中定期使用 MEG。扭转癫痫手术的普遍低利用率可以从 MEG 中受益,但这需要癫痫和 MEG 社区的持续协调推动。