Ehsan Hamid, Wahab Ahsan, Shafqat Muhammad Ammar, Sana Muhammad Khawar, Khalid Farhan, Abdullah Syed Maaz, Jaan Ali, Sheikh Muhammad M, Muneeb Ahmad, Ehsan Sajid, Khan Ali Younas, Iftikhar Raheel, Anwer Faiz
Biohazardous Threat Agents and Emerging Infectious Diseases, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, USA.
University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA.
J Blood Med. 2020 Nov 2;11:405-420. doi: 10.2147/JBM.S277541. eCollection 2020.
The blood transfusion (BT) system in Pakistan is fragmented, demand-driven and depends on weakly regulated transfusion practices. There is a considerable possibility that transfusion-transmissible infections (TTIs) are contributing to the current epidemic of hepatitis B virus (HBV) and hepatitis C virus (HCV) (affecting 7.4% of the general population) in the country. To study this issue, we conducted a systematic review to identify articles related to TTIs and transfusion safety in Pakistan from January 1, 2010 to January 31, 2020. A review of 33 articles met the final criteria for qualitative synthesis. Analysis of these studies showed a cumulative frequency of HBV 2.04%, HCV 2.44%, HIV 0.038%, syphilis 1.1% and malaria 0.11%. The frequency of coinfections among blood donors varied from 0.0099% to 0.35%. The highest number of coinfections were HCV and syphilis, followed by HCV and HBV infections. Syphilis and malaria were tested in only 38% and 46% of all the blood donations in one study. The rate of voluntary non-remunerated donations (VNRDs) was less than 13%, and male donors were 95% to 100% in these studies. There was a significant difference in the frequency of HBV and HCV in VNRDs (0.48%) as compared to replacement donors (RDs) (4.15%). In short, this review shows a high frequency of TTIs, especially HBV, HCV and syphilis in the blood donor population in Pakistan. There is a high dependency on RDs, minimal use of healthy voluntary blood donation practices, inadequate screening of high-risk donors, repeated collections of the blood from RDs, poor quality of screening methods and limited knowledge of donor health. Without standardized safe transfusion practices, there will be an ongoing increase in transmission of TTIs, especially HBV, HCV, syphilis, and HIV leading to a significant adverse public health impact.
巴基斯坦的输血系统分散,由需求驱动,且依赖监管不力的输血操作。输血传播感染(TTIs)很有可能是该国目前乙型肝炎病毒(HBV)和丙型肝炎病毒(HCV)流行(影响7.4%的普通人群)的原因之一。为研究此问题,我们进行了一项系统综述,以识别2010年1月1日至2020年1月31日期间与巴基斯坦TTIs和输血安全相关的文章。对33篇文章的综述符合定性综合的最终标准。对这些研究的分析显示,HBV的累积频率为2.04%,HCV为2.44%,HIV为0.038%,梅毒为1.1%,疟疾为0.11%。献血者中合并感染的频率在0.0099%至0.35%之间。合并感染最多的是HCV和梅毒,其次是HCV和HBV感染。在一项研究中,所有献血中仅38%检测了梅毒,46%检测了疟疾。自愿无偿献血(VNRDs)的比例低于13%,这些研究中的男性献血者占95%至100%。与替代献血者(RDs)(4.15%)相比,VNRDs中HBV和HCV的频率(0.48%)存在显著差异。简而言之,本综述显示巴基斯坦献血人群中TTIs频率较高,尤其是HBV、HCV和梅毒。对RDs的依赖性很高,健康自愿献血操作使用极少,对高危献血者的筛查不足,从RDs重复采血,筛查方法质量差,以及献血者健康知识有限。如果没有标准化的安全输血操作,TTIs的传播,尤其是HBV、HCV、梅毒和HIV的传播将持续增加,对公众健康造成重大不利影响。