Hanoi Medical University, Hanoi, Vietnam.
Department of Orthopedics and Spine, Bachmai University Hospital, Hanoi, Vietnam.
Orthop Surg. 2020 Dec;12(6):2031-2040. doi: 10.1111/os.12792. Epub 2020 Nov 13.
To aim of the present paper was to evaluate the results of halo traction and transarticular screw fixation combined with bone autoplasty in patients with severe atlantoaxial dislocation.
This is a retrospective study of severe cases of atlantoaxial dislocation in nine patients (six men and three women) treated with preoperative halo traction and posterior C1-C2 transarticular screw fixation combined with bone autoplasty from June 2006 to June 2011 at the Saint Paul Hospital (Hanoi). The mean age of patients was 37.48 ± 13.753 years (range, 26-50 years). The possibility of fixing dislocation using a halo apparatus was investigated through a series of preoperative halo corrections performed within a span of 1-2 weeks. For transarticular screw fixation, two transarticular screws were used that were positioned according to the Magerl technique. For bone autoplasty, an iliac crest bone graft approximately 3 × 2 cm in size was used. The postoperative assessment of clinical improvement was performed using the neck disability index (NDI), the American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) impairment scale, and the visual analog scale (VAS) measurement instruments, through the gradation of atlantoaxial dislocation, and via the clivoaxial angle(CAA) index and the space available for cord (SAC) index after 6 months. The image diagnosis demonstrates that all the cases of atlantoaxial dislocations are unstable and correspond to the Fielding and Hawkins type III dislocation. Eight patients underwent complete reduction using the halo fixation device. In one patient, the C1-C2 displacement was manually reduced during surgery. CT scanning revealed that the accuracy of screw placement was 94.4%. The bone fusion rate was 100% after 6 months. Based on the ASIA impairment scale, the preoperative examination of patients revealed grade C injuries in seven patients and grade D injuries in two patients. After surgery, all patients had grade D injuries. Six months after surgery, four patients had moderate self-reported neck disability (30%-48%) and five patients reported mild disability (10%-28%); that is, the patient perception of the neck problem improved. In the postoperative phase, all patients showed an improvement in VAS pain scores and the SAC score returned to the normal range in all patients. The CAA returned to normal in only seven patients; in the other two patients, the CAA returned to a value that was close to normal (145° and 149°).
Through halo traction combined with transarticular screw fixation and bone autoplasty, noticeable postoperative improvements were attained based on the clinical scores for NDI, ASIA, and VAS, as well as SAC and CAA.
本研究旨在评估 Halo 牵引和经关节突螺钉固定联合骨自体移植治疗严重寰枢椎脱位患者的效果。
这是一项回顾性研究,纳入了 2006 年 6 月至 2011 年 6 月在圣保罗医院(河内)接受术前 Halo 牵引和后路 C1-C2 经关节突螺钉固定联合骨自体移植治疗的 9 例(6 男 3 女)严重寰枢椎脱位患者的病例资料。患者平均年龄为 37.48±13.753 岁(范围:26-50 岁)。通过术前 Halo 矫正,在 1-2 周内对使用 Halo 装置固定脱位的可能性进行了一系列研究。经关节突螺钉固定采用了按照 Magerl 技术定位的两根经关节突螺钉。骨自体移植采用约 3×2cm 大小的髂嵴骨移植物。术后通过颈椎残障指数(NDI)、美国脊髓损伤协会(ASIA)损伤量表和视觉模拟量表(VAS)测量仪器评估临床改善情况,通过寰枢椎脱位分级、Clivoaxial 角(CAA)指数和脊髓可利用空间(SAC)指数评估,术后 6 个月进行评估。影像学诊断显示所有寰枢椎脱位均不稳定,符合 Fielding 和 Hawkins Ⅲ型脱位。8 例患者使用 Halo 固定装置完全复位。1 例患者在手术中手动复位 C1-C2 移位。CT 扫描显示螺钉放置准确率为 94.4%。术后 6 个月骨融合率为 100%。根据 ASIA 损伤量表,术前检查 7 例患者为 C 级损伤,2 例患者为 D 级损伤。术后所有患者均为 D 级损伤。术后 6 个月,4 例患者中度自述颈部功能障碍(30%-48%),5 例患者轻度颈部功能障碍(10%-28%),即患者对颈部问题的自我感知有所改善。术后患者 VAS 疼痛评分和 SAC 评分均有所改善,所有患者均恢复至正常范围。仅 7 例患者的 CAA 恢复正常,2 例患者的 CAA 接近正常(145°和 149°)。
通过 Halo 牵引联合经关节突螺钉固定和骨自体移植,术后通过 NDI、ASIA 和 VAS 临床评分以及 SAC 和 CAA 可观察到明显的改善。