Rostami-Tabar Bahman, Rendon-Sanchez Juan F
Cardiff Business School, 3 Colum Drive, CF10 3EU, Cardiff, UK.
Cardiff School of Computer Science and Informatics, Queen's Buildings, 5 The Parade, Roath, CF24 3AA, Cardiff, UK.
Appl Soft Comput. 2021 Mar;100:106932. doi: 10.1016/j.asoc.2020.106932. Epub 2020 Nov 25.
The need to forecast COVID-19 related variables continues to be pressing as the epidemic unfolds. Different efforts have been made, with compartmental models in epidemiology and statistical models such as AutoRegressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA), Exponential Smoothing (ETS) or computing intelligence models. These efforts have proved useful in some instances by allowing decision makers to distinguish different scenarios during the emergency, but their accuracy has been disappointing, forecasts ignore uncertainties and less attention is given to local areas. In this study, we propose a simple Multiple Linear Regression model, optimised to use phone call data to forecast the number of daily confirmed cases. Moreover, we produce a probabilistic forecast that allows decision makers to better deal with risk. Our proposed approach outperforms ARIMA, ETS, Seasonal Naive, Prophet and a regression model without call data, evaluated by three point forecast error metrics, one prediction interval and two probabilistic forecast accuracy measures. The simplicity, interpretability and reliability of the model, obtained in a careful forecasting exercise, is a meaningful contribution to decision makers at local level who acutely need to organise resources in already strained health services. We hope that this model would serve as a building block of other forecasting efforts that on the one hand would help front-line personal and decision makers at local level, and on the other would facilitate the communication with other modelling efforts being made at the national level to improve the way we tackle this pandemic and other similar future challenges.
随着新冠疫情的发展,对与新冠疫情相关变量进行预测的需求依然紧迫。人们已经做出了不同的努力,采用了流行病学中的 compartmental 模型以及统计模型,如自回归积分移动平均模型(ARIMA)、指数平滑法(ETS)或计算智能模型。这些努力在某些情况下已被证明是有用的,能让决策者在紧急情况下区分不同场景,但它们的准确性却令人失望,预测忽略了不确定性,且对局部地区的关注较少。在本研究中,我们提出了一个简单的多元线性回归模型,该模型经过优化,可利用电话数据来预测每日确诊病例数。此外,我们还进行了概率预测,使决策者能够更好地应对风险。通过三点预测误差指标、一个预测区间和两种概率预测准确性度量进行评估,我们提出的方法优于 ARIMA、ETS、季节性朴素模型、Prophet 以及一个没有电话数据的回归模型。在精心的预测过程中获得的该模型的简单性、可解释性和可靠性,对于迫切需要在本就紧张的卫生服务中组织资源的地方决策者而言,是一项有意义的贡献。我们希望这个模型能成为其他预测工作的基石,一方面帮助一线人员和地方决策者,另一方面促进与国家层面正在进行的其他建模工作的交流,以改进我们应对这场疫情及其他类似未来挑战的方式。