van der Ven Ward H, Veelo Denise P, Wijnberge Marije, van der Ster Björn J P, Vlaar Alexander P J, Geerts Bart F
Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Department of Anesthesiology, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Department of Intensive Care, Amsterdam, Netherlands; Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Laboratory of Experimental Intensive Care and Anesthesiology, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Surgery. 2021 Jun;169(6):1300-1303. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2020.09.041. Epub 2020 Dec 11.
This review describes the steps and conclusions from the development and validation of an artificial intelligence algorithm (the Hypotension Prediction Index), one of the first machine learning predictive algorithms used in the operating room environment. The algorithm has been demonstrated to reduce intraoperative hypotension in two randomized controlled trials via real-time prediction of upcoming hypotensive events prompting anesthesiologists to act earlier, more often, and differently in managing impending hypotension. However, the algorithm entails no dynamic learning process that evolves from use in clinical patient care, meaning the algorithm is fixed, and furthermore provides no insight into the decisional process that leads to an early warning for intraoperative hypotension, which makes the algorithm a "black box." Many other artificial intelligence machine learning algorithms have these same disadvantages. Clinical validation of such algorithms is relatively new and requires more standardization, as guidelines are lacking or only now start to be drafted. Before adaptation in clinical practice, impact of artificial intelligence algorithms on clinical behavior, outcomes and economic advantages should be studied too.
本综述描述了一种人工智能算法(低血压预测指数)的开发与验证步骤及结论,该算法是手术室环境中最早使用的机器学习预测算法之一。在两项随机对照试验中,该算法已被证明可通过实时预测即将发生的低血压事件,促使麻醉医生更早、更频繁且以不同方式应对即将发生的低血压,从而减少术中低血压情况。然而,该算法没有因应用于临床患者护理而产生动态学习过程,这意味着该算法是固定不变的,而且对于导致术中低血压早期预警的决策过程也没有提供任何见解,这使得该算法成为一个“黑匣子”。许多其他人工智能机器学习算法也存在这些相同的缺点。此类算法的临床验证相对较新,需要更多标准化,因为目前缺乏相关指南或才刚刚开始起草。在临床实践中采用之前,还应研究人工智能算法对临床行为、结果和经济优势的影响。