Department of Surgery, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA
Department of Surgery, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
BMJ Health Care Inform. 2020 Dec;27(3). doi: 10.1136/bmjhci-2020-100197.
With the unprecedented rise of patient access to clinical documentation through electronic health records, there is a need for health systems to understand best practices for redesigning clinical documentation to support patient needs. This study used an experience-based co-design approach to inform the redesign of cancer pathology reports to improve their patient-centeredness and impact on patient engagement.
Multiple methods for data collection and stakeholder engagement were used, including Delphi prioritisation with breast and colorectal cancer experts (n=78) and focus groups with patients with cancer (n=23) in the Seattle area. Iterative rounds of consensus generation and reflection were used to elicit themes and design recommendations for the development of patient-centred pathology reports on cancer care.
Although each cancer type had nuanced elements to consider, common design requirements emerged around two key themes: (1) clinical documentation language should be framed in a way that informs and engages patients, and (2) clinical documentation format should be leveraged to enhance readability and information flow. Study activities illuminated detailed recommendations to improve the patient-centeredness of pathology reports based on patients' and clinicians' lived experience.
The design requirements that emerged from this study provide a framework that can guide the rapid development of patient-centred pathology reports for all cancer types. Even further, health systems can replicate these methods to guide experience-based co-design of clinical documentation for contexts beyond cancer care.
This work offers practice-based learnings that can more effectively guide health systems in their clinical documentation redesign efforts.
随着电子健康记录使患者前所未有地能够获取临床文档,医疗系统需要了解重新设计临床文档以支持患者需求的最佳实践。本研究采用基于经验的共同设计方法,为癌症病理报告的重新设计提供信息,以提高其以患者为中心的程度并影响患者参与度。
采用了多种数据收集和利益相关者参与方法,包括对乳腺癌和结直肠癌专家(n=78)进行德尔菲优先级排序,以及对西雅图地区的癌症患者(n=23)进行焦点小组讨论。通过反复的共识生成和反思,得出了关于开发以癌症护理为中心的病理报告的主题和设计建议。
尽管每种癌症类型都有需要考虑的细微差别,但出现了两个关键主题的共同设计要求:(1)临床文档语言应以告知和吸引患者的方式进行构建,(2)临床文档格式应利用来提高可读性和信息流程。研究活动根据患者和临床医生的实际经验,阐明了改善病理报告以患者为中心程度的详细建议。
本研究中出现的设计要求提供了一个框架,可以指导所有癌症类型的以患者为中心的病理报告的快速开发。更进一步,医疗系统可以复制这些方法,指导超越癌症护理的临床文档基于经验的共同设计。
这项工作提供了基于实践的学习经验,可以更有效地指导医疗系统进行临床文档重新设计工作。