Herforth Anna W, Wiesmann Doris, Martínez-Steele Euridice, Andrade Giovanna, Monteiro Carlos A
Department of Global Health and Population, Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
Independent Consultant, Schoenwalde, Germany.
Curr Dev Nutr. 2020 Nov 25;4(12):nzaa168. doi: 10.1093/cdn/nzaa168. eCollection 2020 Dec.
Few low-burden indicators of diet quality exist to track trends over time at low cost and with low technical expertise requirements.
The aim was to develop and validate a suite of low-burden indicators to reflect adherence to global dietary recommendations.
Using nationally representative, cross-sectional, quantitative dietary intake datasets from Brazil and the United States, we tested the association of food-group scores with quantitative consumption aligned with 11 global dietary recommendations. We updated the Healthy Diet Indicator (HDI) to include current quantifiable recommendations of the WHO (HDI-2020). We developed 3 food-group-based scores-an overall Global Dietary Recommendations (GDR) score as an indicator of all 11 recommendations composed of 2 subcomponents: GDR-Healthy, an indicator of the recommendations on "healthy" foods, and GDR-Limit, an indicator of the recommendations on dietary components to limit. We tested associations between these scores and the HDI-2020 and its respective subcomponents. We developed 9 dichotomous food-group-based indicators to reflect adherence to the global recommendations for fruits and vegetables, dietary fiber, free sugars, saturated fat, total fat, legumes, nuts and seeds, whole grains, and processed meats. We conducted receiver operating characteristic and sensitivity-specificity analyses to determine whether the dichotomous indicators were valid to predict adherence to the recommendations in both countries.
The GDR score and its subcomponents were moderately to strongly associated with the HDI-2020 and its respective subcomponents (absolute values of rank correlation coefficients ranged from 0.55 to 0.66). Of the 9 dichotomous indicators, 8 largely met the criteria for predicting individual global dietary recommendations in both countries; 1 indicator (total fat) did not perform satisfactorily.
Food-group consumption data can be used to indicate adherence to quantitative global dietary recommendations at population level. These indicators may be used to track progress of countries and populations toward meeting WHO guidance on healthy diets.
几乎没有低成本且对技术专业知识要求低的饮食质量低负担指标来长期跟踪趋势。
旨在开发并验证一套低负担指标,以反映对全球饮食建议的遵循情况。
利用巴西和美国具有全国代表性的横断面定量饮食摄入数据集,我们测试了食物组得分与符合11项全球饮食建议的定量消费量之间的关联。我们更新了健康饮食指标(HDI),纳入了世界卫生组织当前的可量化建议(HDI - 2020)。我们制定了3个基于食物组的得分——一个总体全球饮食建议(GDR)得分,作为所有11项建议的指标,由2个子成分组成:GDR - 健康,“健康”食物建议的指标,以及GDR - 限制,限制饮食成分建议的指标。我们测试了这些得分与HDI - 2020及其各自子成分之间的关联。我们制定了9个基于食物组的二分指标,以反映对水果和蔬菜、膳食纤维、游离糖、饱和脂肪、总脂肪、豆类、坚果和种子、全谷物以及加工肉类的全球建议的遵循情况。我们进行了受试者工作特征分析和敏感性 - 特异性分析,以确定二分指标在两个国家是否能有效预测对建议的遵循情况。
GDR得分及其子成分与HDI - 2020及其各自子成分呈中度至高度相关(等级相关系数的绝对值范围为0.55至0.66)。在9个二分指标中,8个在很大程度上满足了在两个国家预测个体全球饮食建议的标准;1个指标(总脂肪)表现不佳。
食物组消费数据可用于表明在人群层面上对全球定量饮食建议的遵循情况。这些指标可用于跟踪各国和各人群在实现世界卫生组织关于健康饮食指导方面的进展。