Department of Psychology, University of Maryland, Baltimore County.
Department of Psychology, Koc University.
Dev Psychol. 2021 Feb;57(2):284-301. doi: 10.1037/dev0001136. Epub 2020 Dec 21.
Maternal control is a major dimension of parenting and has different meanings, practices, and potential consequences across cultures. The present study aimed to identify and compare mothers' conceptualizations of parenting control across four cultures to reveal a more nuanced understanding regarding the meaning and practices of control: European American, Chinese immigrant, Korean immigrant, and Turkish. Using a semistructured open-ended interview, 100 European American, 102 U.S. Chinese immigrant, 103 U.S. Korean immigrant, and 109 Turkish mothers of preschool-aged children reported the ratings of importance, specific reasons, and strategies for exerting control over their children in daily life. Results revealed both shared and unique conceptualizations of maternal control across four cultures. Specifically, all mothers reported that it is important to express maternal control over their children in order to set behavioral norms/standards, maintain child safety, support social relations and respect for others, provide guidance, and guide moral development. Moreover, mothers discussed utilizing nonphysical punishment, setting and maintaining rules, reasoning/negotiating, consistency, physical punishment and verbal control, showing parents' serious/stern attitude, correction, and psychological control forms of control. However, the levels at which mothers emphasize the different reasons and strategies varied across cultures, reflecting culturally emphasized values. The findings of the present study further enrich our understanding of the complexities of maternal control across cultures. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).
母亲控制是养育的一个主要方面,在不同文化中具有不同的含义、实践和潜在后果。本研究旨在识别和比较来自四个不同文化的母亲在养育控制方面的概念化,以更细致地了解控制的含义和实践:欧洲裔美国人、中国移民、韩国移民和土耳其人。本研究采用半结构式开放式访谈,对 100 名欧洲裔美国母亲、102 名美国中国移民母亲、103 名美国韩国移民母亲和 109 名土耳其学龄前儿童母亲进行了访谈,让她们报告在日常生活中对孩子实施控制的重要性、具体原因和策略的评分。研究结果揭示了四个文化中母亲控制的共同和独特概念化。具体来说,所有母亲都报告说,表达对孩子的母性控制对于设定行为规范/标准、维护儿童安全、支持社会关系和尊重他人、提供指导以及引导道德发展非常重要。此外,母亲们讨论了使用非身体惩罚、制定和维护规则、说理/谈判、一致性、身体惩罚和言语控制、表现出父母的严肃/严厉态度、纠正以及心理控制形式的控制。然而,母亲们强调不同原因和策略的程度因文化而异,反映了文化上强调的价值观。本研究的发现进一步丰富了我们对跨文化背景下母亲控制的复杂性的理解。(心理学信息数据库记录(c)2021 APA,保留所有权利)。