Department of Psychology, York University, 4700 Keele St. W., Toronto, ON, M3J1P3, Canada.
Psychon Bull Rev. 2021 Jun;28(3):732-749. doi: 10.3758/s13423-020-01853-1. Epub 2021 Jan 6.
We acquire a lot of information about the world through texts, which can be categorized at the broadest level into two primary genres: narratives and exposition. Stories and essays differ across a variety of dimensions, including structure and content, with numerous theories hypothesizing that stories are easier to understand and recall than essays. However, empirical work in this area has yielded mixed results. To synthesize research in this area, we conducted a meta-analysis of experiments in which memory and/or comprehension of narrative and expository texts was investigated. Based on over 75 unique samples and data from more than 33,000 participants, we found that stories were more easily understood and better recalled than essays. Moreover, this result was robust, not influenced by the inclusion of a single effect-size or single study, and not moderated by various study characteristics. This finding has implications for any domain in which acquiring and retaining information is important.
我们通过文本获取了大量关于世界的信息,可以在最广泛的层面上将其分为两类主要体裁:叙事和说明。故事和论文在结构和内容等多个方面存在差异,许多理论假设故事比论文更容易理解和回忆。然而,该领域的实证工作得出的结果喜忧参半。为了综合该领域的研究,我们对研究叙事和说明性文本的记忆和/或理解的实验进行了元分析。基于超过 75 个独特样本和来自超过 33000 名参与者的数据,我们发现故事比论文更容易理解和更好地回忆。此外,该结果是稳健的,不受单个效应大小或单个研究的影响,也不受各种研究特征的调节。这一发现对任何需要获取和保留信息的领域都具有重要意义。