Department of Public Health, Laboratory for Mother and Child Health, Istituto di Ricerche Farmacologiche Mario Negri IRCCS, Via Mario Negri 2, 20156, Milan, Italy.
BMC Psychiatry. 2021 Jan 8;21(1):20. doi: 10.1186/s12888-020-03027-8.
Quarantine as a preventive action to reduce people's exposure to a contagious disease has substantial psychological impact. We aimed to collect information on psychologically distressing experiences of Italians living in quarantine during the COVID-19 pandemic.
From 6 to 20 April 2020 participants filled out an online questionnaire. Demographic and physical symptoms data from the prior 14 days of quarantine were collected. Psychological impact of quarantine was assessed by the COVID-19 Peritraumatic Distress Index (CPDI).
In all, 20,158 participants completed the online survey. Of these, 11,910 (59.1%) were from Lombardy, the region with 37.7% of positive cases identified during the survey period. 30.1% of responders were male. About half (55.9%) of responders were 18-50 years old, 54.3% had a tertiary level of education, 69.5% were workers, 84.1% were living in houses with ≥3 rooms, and 13.7% were living alone. 9.7% had had contact with COVID-19 positive people. Of all responders, 9978 (48.6%) reported a psychological impact, 8897 (43.4%) of whom reported mild or moderate and 1081 (5.2%) severe psychological impact. The multivariate analysis, after adjustments, showed that an increasing CPDI score was associated with gender (female), first-second educational level, being unemployed, living in a ≤2 room house, having had new health problems during the previous 14 days, and not having been out of the house in the previous week. Concerning the type of psychological distress, 2003 responders (9.9%) reported moderate to severe depressive symptoms, 1131 (5.5%) moderate to severe anxiety symptoms, and 802 (3.9%) moderate to severe physical symptoms. A positive correlation was found between responder rate (per 10.000 residents) and positive COVID-19 cases (per 10.000 residents) by region (r = + 0.83, p = < 0.0001), and between responder rate and region latitude (r = + 0.91, p = < 0.0001), with a greater response rate in the north. Considering Lombardy Region responders, a negative correlation between CPDI score and distance from place of residence to the red zone (Nembro-Alzano) was found. Higher prevalence of psychological distress was found up to 25 km away from the red zone and, in particular, severe distress up to 15 km.
Policy makers and mental health professionals should be aware of quarantine's adverse mental health consequences. Factors influencing the success of quarantine and infection control practices for both disease containment and community recovery should be identified and additional support to vulnerable persons at increased risk of adverse psychological and social consequences of quarantine should be guaranteed.
为减少人们接触传染病的风险而采取的隔离措施会产生重大的心理影响。本研究旨在收集意大利人在 COVID-19 大流行期间隔离期间心理困扰的相关信息。
2020 年 4 月 6 日至 20 日期间,参与者填写了在线问卷。收集了隔离前 14 天的人口统计学和身体症状数据。使用 COVID-19 创伤后应激障碍指数(CPDI)评估隔离的心理影响。
共有 20158 名参与者完成了在线调查。其中,11910 名(59.1%)来自伦巴第大区,该地区在调查期间发现的阳性病例占 37.7%。应答者中 30.1%为男性。约一半(55.9%)的应答者年龄在 18-50 岁之间,54.3%具有高等教育水平,69.5%为工人,84.1%居住在有≥3 个房间的房屋中,13.7%独居。9.7%与 COVID-19 阳性患者有过接触。在所有应答者中,有 9978 人(48.6%)报告存在心理影响,其中 8897 人(43.4%)报告轻度或中度,1081 人(5.2%)报告重度心理影响。多变量分析显示,CPDI 评分升高与性别(女性)、第一/二教育水平、失业、居住在≤2 个房间的房屋中、在过去 14 天内出现新的健康问题以及在过去一周内未离开家有关。关于心理困扰的类型,有 2003 名应答者(9.9%)报告有中度至重度抑郁症状,1131 名(5.5%)有中度至重度焦虑症状,802 名(3.9%)有中度至重度身体症状。按地区划分,应答者人数(每 10000 人)与 COVID-19 阳性病例数(每 10000 人)之间存在正相关(r=+0.83,p<0.0001),与地区纬度(r=+0.91,p<0.0001)之间也存在正相关,北部地区的应答者比例较高。考虑到伦巴第大区的应答者,发现 CPDI 评分与居住地到红色区域(Nembro-Alzano)的距离之间存在负相关。在距红色区域 25 公里范围内发现了更高的心理困扰发生率,尤其是在距红色区域 15 公里范围内发现了严重的心理困扰。
政策制定者和心理健康专业人员应意识到隔离对心理健康的不利影响。应确定影响隔离和感染控制措施成功的因素,以控制疾病和社区恢复,应为处于隔离不利心理和社会后果风险较高的弱势群体提供额外支持。