Ahmadi Samira, Siragy Tarique, Nantel Julie
School of Human Kinetics, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2021 Feb 1;18(1):20. doi: 10.1186/s12984-021-00807-5.
Regularity, quantified by sample entropy (SampEn), has been extensively used as a gait stability measure. Yet, there is no consensus on the calculation process and variant approaches, e.g. single-scale SampEn with and without incorporating a time delay greater than one, multiscale SampEn, and complexity index, have been used to calculate the regularity of kinematic or kinetic signals. The aim of the present study was to test the discriminatory performance of the abovementioned approaches during single and dual-task walking in people with Parkinson's disease (PD).
Seventeen individuals with PD were included in this study. Participants completed two walking trials that included single and dual-task conditions. The secondary task was word searching with twelve words randomly appearing in the participants' visual field. Trunk linear acceleration at sternum level, linear acceleration of the center of gravity, and angular velocity of feet, shanks, and thighs, each in three planes of motion were collected. The regularity of signals was computed using approaches mentioned above for single and dual-task conditions.
Incorporating a time delay greater than one and considering multiple scales helped better distinguish between single and dual-task walking. For all signals, the complexity index, defined as the summary of multiscale SampEn analysis, was the most efficient discriminatory index between single-task walking and dual-tasking in people with Parkinson's disease. Specifically, the complexity index of the trunk linear acceleration of the center of gravity distinguished between the two walking conditions in all three planes of motion.
The significant results observed across the 24 signals studied in this study are illustrative examples of the complexity index's potential as a gait feature for classifying different walking conditions.
通过样本熵(SampEn)量化的规律性已被广泛用作步态稳定性的衡量指标。然而,关于计算过程和变体方法尚未达成共识,例如,已使用包含和不包含大于1的时间延迟的单尺度SampEn、多尺度SampEn和复杂度指数来计算运动学或动力学信号的规律性。本研究的目的是测试上述方法在帕金森病(PD)患者单任务和双任务行走过程中的辨别性能。
本研究纳入了17名PD患者。参与者完成了两项行走试验,包括单任务和双任务条件。次要任务是在参与者视野中随机出现12个单词的情况下进行单词搜索。收集了胸骨水平的躯干线性加速度、重心的线性加速度以及脚、小腿和大腿在三个运动平面上的角速度。使用上述方法计算单任务和双任务条件下信号的规律性。
纳入大于1的时间延迟并考虑多个尺度有助于更好地区分单任务和双任务行走。对于所有信号,定义为多尺度SampEn分析总和的复杂度指数是帕金森病患者单任务行走和双任务行走之间最有效的辨别指数。具体而言,重心的躯干线性加速度的复杂度指数在所有三个运动平面上区分了两种行走条件。
本研究中在24个信号上观察到的显著结果是复杂度指数作为用于分类不同行走条件的步态特征的潜力的说明性示例。