McCamley John D, Denton William, Arnold Andrew, Raffalt Peter C, Yentes Jennifer M
MORE Foundation, 18444 N 25 Ave., Suite 110, Phoenix, Arizona, 85023 USA;
Center for Research in Human Movement Variability, Department of Biomechanics, University of Nebraska at Omaha, 6160 University Drive, Omaha, Nebraska, 68182-0860 USA;
Entropy (Basel). 2018 Oct;20(10). doi: 10.3390/e20100764. Epub 2018 Oct 5.
Sample entropy (SE) has relative consistency using biologically-derived, discrete data >500 data points. For certain populations, collecting this quantity is not feasible and continuous data has been used. The effect of using continuous versus discrete data on SE is unknown, nor are the relative effects of sampling rate and input parameters (comparison vector length) and (tolerance). Eleven subjects walked for 10-minutes and continuous joint angles (480Hz) were calculated for each lower-extremity joint. Data were downsampled (240, 120, 60Hz) and discrete range-of-motion was calculated. SE was quantified for angles and range-of-motion at all sampling rates and multiple combinations of parameters. A differential relationship between joints was observed between range-of-motion and joint angles. Range-of-motion SE showed no difference; whereas, joint angle SE significantly decreased from ankle to knee to hip. To confirm findings from biological data, continuous signals with manipulations to frequency, amplitude, and both were generated and underwent similar analysis to the biological data. In general, changes to , , and sampling rate had a greater effect on continuous compared to discrete data. Discrete data was robust to sampling rate and . It is recommended that different data types not be compared and discrete data be used for SE.
样本熵(SE)对于超过500个数据点的生物衍生离散数据具有相对一致性。对于某些人群,收集这个数量的数据是不可行的,因此使用了连续数据。使用连续数据与离散数据对样本熵的影响尚不清楚,采样率以及输入参数(比较向量长度)和(容差)的相对影响也不清楚。11名受试者步行10分钟,计算每个下肢关节的连续关节角度(480Hz)。对数据进行降采样(240、120、60Hz)并计算离散运动范围。在所有采样率和多种参数组合下,对角度和运动范围的样本熵进行量化。观察到运动范围和关节角度之间关节存在差异关系。运动范围的样本熵没有差异;然而,关节角度的样本熵从脚踝到膝盖再到臀部显著降低。为了证实生物数据的结果,生成了对频率、幅度以及两者都进行了操作的连续信号,并对其进行了与生物数据类似的分析。一般来说,与离散数据相比,对、和采样率的改变对连续数据有更大的影响。离散数据对采样率和具有鲁棒性。建议不要比较不同的数据类型,并且样本熵应使用离散数据。