Vogt Nadine A, Vriezen Ellen, Nwosu Andrea, Sargeant Jan M
Department of Population Medicine, Ontario Veterinary College, University of Guelph, Guelph, ON, Canada.
Front Vet Sci. 2021 Jan 18;7:618301. doi: 10.3389/fvets.2020.618301. eCollection 2020.
Honey has a history of medicinal use that predates written records. In recent decades, there has been renewed interest in the use of honey in human medicine, particularly for the treatment of burns and other wounds. Several recent systematic reviews in the human literature have demonstrated the efficacy of honey in the treatment of a number of conditions, including burns, wounds and oral mucositis. The goal of this scoping review was to describe the nature and extent of the current body of evidence addressing the medicinal use of natural honey and/or its derivatives in animals. Although the focus of this review was the veterinary literature, all animal species except insects and humans were eligible, including animals used for biomedical research. Electronic databases searched were MEDLINE, CAB Abstracts, AGRICOLA, Web of Science Core Collection, and Web of Science SciELO Citation Index. A total of 397 articles reporting 436 primary research studies were included in this review. The majority of the articles were biomedical research articles ( = 350); fewer veterinary research articles were identified ( = 47). Apart from one systematic review, all biomedical studies were challenge trials. Most veterinary studies were case reports/series ( = 23), followed by challenge trials ( = 18) and controlled trials ( = 8). The animal species examined within veterinary articles consisted primarily of dogs, horses, cats and cattle, whereas the majority of biomedical research articles examined rats and mice. Wound healing was the most common indication examined; other indications examined included the prevention or treatment of gastric ulcers, bacterial and parasitic infections, toxic exposures, metabolic conditions (e.g., diabetes) and neoplasia. The majority of interventions consisted of non-medical grade honey ( = 412/436), followed by medical-grade honey ( = 29/436) and derivatives of natural honey ( = 9/436). With much of the current veterinary literature consisting of case reports and case series, high-quality primary veterinary research in the form of controlled trials or challenge trials is needed to advance this field, as well as to provide sound data for evidence-based assessments of the efficacy of honey in clinical veterinary practise.
蜂蜜的药用历史早于文字记载。近几十年来,人们对蜂蜜在人类医学中的应用重新产生了兴趣,尤其是用于治疗烧伤和其他伤口。最近人类文献中的几项系统评价表明,蜂蜜在治疗多种病症方面具有疗效,包括烧伤、伤口和口腔黏膜炎。本范围综述的目的是描述当前关于天然蜂蜜和/或其衍生物在动物医学应用方面的证据的性质和范围。尽管本综述的重点是兽医文献,但除昆虫和人类外的所有动物物种均符合条件,包括用于生物医学研究的动物。检索的电子数据库有MEDLINE、CAB文摘数据库、AGRICOLA、科学网核心合集以及科学网SciELO引文索引。本综述共纳入了397篇报告436项初级研究的文章。大多数文章是生物医学研究文章(n = 350);鉴定出的兽医研究文章较少(n = 47)。除了一项系统评价外,所有生物医学研究都是挑战试验。大多数兽医研究是病例报告/系列(n = 23),其次是挑战试验(n = 18)和对照试验(n = 8)。兽医文章中研究的动物物种主要包括狗、马、猫和牛,而大多数生物医学研究文章研究的是大鼠和小鼠。伤口愈合是最常见的研究适应症;研究的其他适应症包括预防或治疗胃溃疡、细菌和寄生虫感染、中毒、代谢性疾病(如糖尿病)和肿瘤。大多数干预措施使用的是非医用级蜂蜜(n = 412/436),其次是医用级蜂蜜(n = 29/436)和天然蜂蜜衍生物(n = 9/436)。由于当前的大多数兽医文献都是病例报告和病例系列,因此需要高质量的以对照试验或挑战试验形式的初级兽医研究来推动该领域的发展,并为基于证据评估蜂蜜在临床兽医实践中的疗效提供可靠数据。