Panchal Aarti C, Asthana Geeta
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Government Dental College and Hospital, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.
J Conserv Dent. 2020 May-Jun;23(3):254-258. doi: 10.4103/JCD.JCD_325_19. Epub 2020 Dec 4.
This study aimed to evaluate the thickness of oxygen inhibition layer (OIL), produced on various composite materials, and to compare their interlayer shear bond strength (SBS), by treating the OIL with various agents.
The thickness of OIL of three different composite materials (120 specimens divided into three groups) Group 1 - Ivoclar Tetric N-Ceram (nanohybrid composite), Group 2 - Ivoclar Te Econom Plus (microhybrid composite), and Group 3 - GC EverX Posterior (a short glass fiber-reinforced composite) was evaluated. Each group was divided into four subgroups (A, B, C, and D) depending on the surface treatment given - no surface treatment (control group), ethanol, water spray, and grinding with SiC paper. This was followed by interlayer SBS testing.
The data were statistically analyzed using ANOVA at a significance level of < 0.05. Tukey's analysis was performed following ANOVA to determine differences among the groups.
The control group showed higher SBS irrespective of the type of composite material. The group treated with SiC paper resulted in the lowest interlayer SBS among all groups. Glass fiber composite showed higher interlayer SBS compared to both nanohybrid and microhybrid composites, irrespective of the surface treatment given.
The OIL, which acts as an intermediate layer, is retained on the surface of the composite even after treatment with ethanol and water spray. The presence of an OIL improved the interlayer SBS of two adjacent composite layers and led to more durable adhesion. Rather, the absence of an OIL adversely affected the bond strength and led to adhesive interfacial failures.
本研究旨在评估不同复合材料上产生的氧抑制层(OIL)的厚度,并通过用不同试剂处理OIL来比较它们的层间剪切粘结强度(SBS)。
评估三种不同复合材料(120个样本分为三组)的OIL厚度,第1组 - 义获嘉Tetric N-Ceram(纳米混合复合材料),第2组 - 义获嘉Te Econom Plus(微混合复合材料),第3组 - GC EverX Posterior(短玻璃纤维增强复合材料)。根据表面处理情况,每组又分为四个亚组(A、B、C和D) - 无表面处理(对照组)、乙醇处理、喷水处理以及用碳化硅砂纸打磨处理。随后进行层间SBS测试。
使用方差分析对数据进行统计学分析,显著性水平<0.05。方差分析后进行Tukey分析以确定组间差异。
无论复合材料类型如何,对照组均显示出较高的SBS。在所有组中,用碳化硅砂纸处理的组导致层间SBS最低。无论进行何种表面处理,玻璃纤维复合材料与纳米混合和微混合复合材料相比,均显示出较高的层间SBS。
作为中间层的OIL即使在用乙醇和喷水处理后仍保留在复合材料表面。OIL的存在改善了两个相邻复合层的层间SBS,并导致更持久的粘结。相反,OIL的缺失会对粘结强度产生不利影响,并导致粘结界面失效。