Evans L
Operating Sciences Department, General Motors Research Laboratories, Warren, MI 48090.
Accid Anal Prev. 1988 Apr;20(2):129-36. doi: 10.1016/0001-4575(88)90029-2.
Restraint system effectiveness for rear seat adult (16 years or older) car occupants is estimated by applying the double pair comparison method to Fatal Accident Reporting System (FARS) data for 1975 through 1985. As this data set contains information on fatal crashes only, the results apply exclusively to fatalities, and should not be generalized to other levels of injury. Rear seat occupants coded as using any restraint system are assumed to be using the lap belt only. Occupants in all four outboard seating positions (that is, driver and right front passenger, right and left rear passengers) serve as "other" occupants. Disaggregating the "other" occupant by restraint use generates six estimates of restraint system effectiveness for each of the two rear outboard positions. Insufficient data precluded estimating effectiveness for the center rear (or center front) positions, and also use of these occupants as "other" occupants. Average restraint system effectiveness for the two outboard rear seating positions is estimated as (18 +/- 9)%, where the error limit indicates one standard error. These estimates suggest that there is a 39 in 40 chance that rear lap belts reduce fatality likelihood, but a less than 1 in 10 chance that the reduction exceeds 30%.
通过对1975年至1985年的致命事故报告系统(FARS)数据应用双对比较法,估算了后排成年(16岁及以上)汽车乘客约束系统的有效性。由于该数据集仅包含致命碰撞的信息,因此结果仅适用于死亡情况,不应推广到其他伤害程度。编码为使用任何约束系统的后排乘客假定仅使用安全带。所有四个外侧座位位置的乘客(即驾驶员和右前排乘客、右后排和左后排乘客)作为“其他”乘客。按约束使用情况对“其他”乘客进行分类,可为两个后排外侧位置中的每一个生成六种约束系统有效性估计值。数据不足妨碍了对后排中间(或前排中间)位置的有效性估计,也妨碍了将这些乘客用作“其他”乘客。两个外侧后排座位位置的约束系统平均有效性估计为(18±9)%,其中误差极限表示一个标准误差。这些估计表明,后排安全带降低死亡可能性的概率为40分之39,但降低幅度超过30%的概率小于十分之一。