Sahraei Elham, Digges Kennerly, Marzougui Dhafer
The National Crash Analysis Center, The George Washington University.
Ann Adv Automot Med. 2010;54:149-58.
Effectiveness of the rear seat in protecting occupants of different age groups in frontal crashes for 2000-2009 model years (MY) of vehicles was estimated and compared to 1990-1999 model years of vehicles. The objective was to determine the effectiveness of the rear seat compared to the front seat for various age groups in newer model year vehicles. The double paired comparison method was used to estimate relative effectiveness. For belted adults of the 25-49 age group, the fatality reduction effectiveness of the rear seat compared to the right front seat was 25 % (CI 11% to 36%), in the 1990-1999 model year vehicles. The relative effectiveness was -31% (CI -63% to -5%) for the same population, in the 2000-2009 model year vehicles. For restrained children 0-8 years old, the relative effectiveness was 55% (CI 48% to 61%) when the vehicles were of the 1990-1999 period. The level of effectiveness for this age group was reduced to 25% (CI -4% to 46%) in the 2000-2009 MYs of vehicles. Results for other age groups of belted occupants have followed a similar trend. All belted adult occupants of 25+ years old were significantly less protected in rear seats as compared to right front seats in the 2000-2009 model years of vehicles. For unbelted occupants however, rear seats were still a safer position than front seats, even in the 2000-2009 model years of vehicles.
对2000 - 2009车型年(MY)车辆在正面碰撞中后排座椅对不同年龄组乘员的保护效果进行了评估,并与1990 - 1999车型年的车辆进行了比较。目的是确定在较新车型年的车辆中,后排座椅相对于前排座椅对不同年龄组的保护效果。采用双配对比较法来估计相对有效性。在1990 - 1999车型年的车辆中,对于25 - 49岁年龄组系安全带的成年人,后排座椅相对于右前座椅的死亡减少有效性为25%(置信区间11%至36%)。在2000 - 2009车型年的车辆中,同一人群的相对有效性为 - 31%(置信区间 - 63%至 - 5%)。对于0 - 8岁系安全带的儿童,在1990 - 1999年期间的车辆中,相对有效性为55%(置信区间48%至61%)。在2000 - 2009车型年的车辆中,该年龄组的有效性水平降至25%(置信区间 - 4%至46%)。其他系安全带乘员年龄组的结果也呈现出类似趋势。在2000 - 2009车型年的车辆中,所有25岁及以上系安全带的成年乘员在后排座椅上受到的保护明显不如右前座椅。然而,对于未系安全带的乘员,即使在2000 - 2009车型年的车辆中,后排座椅仍然比前排座椅更安全。