Faculty of Social Welfare, Department of Health and Welfare, Shizuoka University of Welfare, Yaizu, Japan.
PLoS One. 2021 Feb 18;16(2):e0247099. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0247099. eCollection 2021.
The present study aims to clarify the effects of bilateral contraction on the ability and accuracy of rapid force production at the submaximal force level. Eleven right-handed participants performed rapid gripping as fast and precisely as they could in unilateral (UL) and bilateral (BL) contractions in a standing position. Participants were required to impinge a grip force of 30% and 50% of their maximal voluntary contraction (MVC). Ability and accuracy of rapid force production were evaluated using the rate of force development (RFD) and force error, respectively. The data analysis did not observe a significant difference in the RFD between UL and BL contractions in both 30% (420±86 vs. 413±106%MVC/s, p = 0.34) and 50% of MVC (622±84 vs. 619±103%MVC/s, p = 0.77). Although the RFD to peak force ratio (RFD/PF) in BL contraction was lower than in UL in 30% of MVC (12.8±2.8 vs. 13.4±2.7, p = 0.003), it indicated a small effect size (d = 0.22) of the difference between UL and BL in RFD/PF. The absolute force error of BL contraction was higher than of UL contraction in 30% (4.67±2.64 vs. 3.64±1.13%MVC, p = 0.005) and 50% of MVC (5.53±2.94 vs. 3.53±0.71%MVC, p = 0.009). In addition, medium and large effect sizes were observed in absolute force error from 30% (d = 0.51) and 50% of MVC (d = 0.94), respectively. In conclusion, results indicated that the bilateral contraction reduced in the ability and accuracy of rapid force production at the submaximal force level. Nevertheless, the present results suggest that the noticeable effect of bilateral contraction is more prominent on the accuracy than in the ability of rapid force production at the submaximal force level.
本研究旨在阐明双侧收缩对次最大力水平快速力量产生的能力和准确性的影响。11 名右利手参与者以站立姿势分别进行单侧(UL)和双侧(BL)收缩,尽可能快速且精确地进行快速抓握。参与者需要施加 30%和 50%最大自主收缩(MVC)的握力。通过力发展速率(RFD)和力误差分别评估快速力量产生的能力和准确性。数据分析未观察到 UL 和 BL 收缩在 30%(420±86 与 413±106%MVC/s,p = 0.34)和 50%MVC 时的 RFD 存在显著差异(622±84 与 619±103%MVC/s,p = 0.77)。尽管 BL 收缩时的 RFD 与峰值力比(RFD/PF)在 30%MVC 时低于 UL(12.8±2.8 与 13.4±2.7,p = 0.003),但 RFD/PF 之间的差异具有较小的效应量(d = 0.22)。BL 收缩的绝对力误差高于 UL 收缩在 30%(4.67±2.64 与 3.64±1.13%MVC,p = 0.005)和 50%MVC(5.53±2.94 与 3.53±0.71%MVC,p = 0.009)时。此外,在 30%(d = 0.51)和 50%MVC(d = 0.94)时,绝对力误差均观察到中等和较大的效应量。总之,结果表明,双侧收缩降低了次最大力水平的快速力量产生的能力和准确性。然而,目前的结果表明,在次最大力水平,双侧收缩对快速力量产生的准确性的影响比能力更为明显。