Department of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine, Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, De Boelelaan, 1117, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Barcelonaβeta Brain Research Center (BBRC), Pasqual Maragall Foundation, Barcelona, Spain.
Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2021 Jul;48(7):2169-2182. doi: 10.1007/s00259-020-05174-2. Epub 2021 Feb 22.
To investigate the sensitivity of visual read (VR) to detect early amyloid pathology and the overall utility of regional VR.
[F]Flutemetamol PET images of 497 subjects (ALFA+ N = 352; ADC N = 145) were included. Scans were visually assessed according to product guidelines, recording the number of positive regions (0-5) and a final negative/positive classification. Scans were quantified using the standard and regional Centiloid (CL) method. The agreement between VR-based classification and published CL-based cut-offs for early (CL = 12) and established (CL = 30) pathology was determined. An optimal CL cut-off maximizing Youden's index was derived. Global and regional CL quantification was compared to VR. Finally, 28 post-mortem cases from the [F]flutemetamol phase III trial were included to assess the percentage agreement between VR and neuropathological classification of neuritic plaque density.
VR showed excellent agreement against CL = 12 (κ = .89, 95.2%) and CL = 30 (κ = .88, 95.4%) cut-offs. ROC analysis resulted in an optimal CL = 17 cut-off against VR (sensitivity = 97.9%, specificity = 97.8%). Each additional positive VR region corresponded to a clear increase in global CL. Regional VR was also associated with regional CL quantification. Compared to mCERAD-based classification (i.e., any region mCERAD > 1.5), VR was in agreement in 89.3% of cases, with 13 true negatives, 12 true positives, and 3 false positives (FP). Regional sparse-to-moderate neuritic and substantial diffuse Aβ plaque was observed in all FP cases. Regional VR was also associated with regional plaque density.
VR is an appropriate method for assessing early amyloid pathology and that grading the extent of visual amyloid positivity could present clinical value.
研究视觉读片(VR)检测早期淀粉样蛋白病理的敏感性和区域 VR 的整体效用。
共纳入 497 例受试者的[F]氟脱氧葡萄糖 PET 图像(ALFA+ N=352;ADC N=145)。根据产品指南进行扫描的视觉评估,记录阳性区域的数量(0-5)和最终的阴性/阳性分类。使用标准和区域百分位(CL)方法对扫描进行定量。根据早期(CL=12)和已建立(CL=30)病理的 CL 截断值,确定基于 VR 分类和基于 CL 的截断值的一致性。通过最大约登指数推导最佳 CL 截断值。比较了全局和区域 CL 定量与 VR。最后,纳入来自[F]氟脱氧葡萄糖 III 期试验的 28 例尸检病例,以评估 VR 与神经纤维斑块密度的神经病理学分类之间的百分比一致性。
VR 与 CL=12(κ=0.89,95.2%)和 CL=30(κ=0.88,95.4%)截断值具有极好的一致性。ROC 分析得出了最佳的 CL=17 截断值与 VR 相对应(敏感性=97.9%,特异性=97.8%)。每个额外的阳性 VR 区域都对应于全局 CL 的明显增加。区域 VR 也与区域 CL 定量相关。与 mCERAD 分类(即任何区域 mCERAD>1.5)相比,VR 在 89.3%的病例中一致,13 例为真阴性,12 例为真阳性,3 例为假阳性(FP)。所有 FP 病例均观察到区域性稀疏到中度神经纤维和大量弥漫性 Aβ 斑块。区域 VR 也与区域斑块密度相关。
VR 是评估早期淀粉样蛋白病理的合适方法,对视觉淀粉样蛋白阳性程度进行分级可能具有临床价值。