Thompson Esi E
Communication Science Unit, The Media School, Indiana University Bloomington, Bloomington, IN 47405, USA.
Vaccines (Basel). 2021 Feb 19;9(2):177. doi: 10.3390/vaccines9020177.
In June 2015, proposed Ebola vaccine trials were suspended by the Ministry of Health of Ghana amid protests from members of parliament and the general public. Scholarship has often focused on the design, development, and administration of vaccines. Of equal importance are the social issues surrounding challenges with vaccine trials and their implementation. The purpose of this study was to analyze discourses in the media that led to the suspension of the 2015 Ebola vaccine trials in Ghana. I use a sociological lens drawing on moral panic and risk society theories. The study qualitatively analyzed discourses in 18 semi-structured interviews with media workers, selected online publications, and user comments about the Ebola vaccine trials. The findings show that discourses surrounding the Ebola vaccine trials drew on cultural, biomedical, historical, and even contextual knowledge and circumstances to concretize risk discourses and garner support for their positions. Historical, political, and cultural underpinnings have a strong influence on biomedical practices and how they are (not) accepted. This study highlights the complexity and challenges of undertaking much needed vaccine tests in societies where the notion of drug trials has underlying historical and sociological baggage that determine whether (or not) the trials proceed.
2015年6月,在国会议员和公众的抗议声中,加纳卫生部暂停了拟议中的埃博拉疫苗试验。学术研究常常聚焦于疫苗的设计、研发和管理。同样重要的是围绕疫苗试验及其实施所面临挑战的社会问题。本研究的目的是分析媒体上导致2015年加纳埃博拉疫苗试验暂停的相关论述。我运用社会学视角,借鉴道德恐慌和风险社会理论。该研究对18次针对媒体工作者的半结构化访谈、选定的在线出版物以及关于埃博拉疫苗试验的用户评论中的论述进行了定性分析。研究结果表明,围绕埃博拉疫苗试验的论述借鉴了文化、生物医学、历史乃至具体情境知识和情况,以使风险论述具体化,并为其立场赢得支持。历史、政治和文化基础对生物医学实践及其(不)被接受的方式有着强烈影响。本研究凸显了在药物试验观念带有决定试验能否进行的潜在历史和社会学包袱的社会中,开展急需的疫苗测试的复杂性和挑战。