Yeung Andy Wai Kan
Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Applied Oral Sciences and Community Dental Care, Faculty of Dentistry, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Front Psychol. 2021 Feb 18;12:631516. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2021.631516. eCollection 2021.
Sigmund Freud is occasionally perceived as outdated and his work no longer relevant to academia. The citing papers (CPs) that cited Freud works were collected from Web of Science and analyzed. The 10 most common research areas of the CPs were noted, and the overall volume of the respective bodies of literature were retrieved. I computed the annual percentage of the respective bodies of literature that cited Freud. On a separate note, I computed the annual percentage of citations coming from psychology and psychiatry. Results based on 42,571 CPs found that psychology accounted for over half of the citations to Freud. The percentage of psychology papers citing Freud declined gradually from around 3% in the late 1950s to around 1% in the 2010s, in an extent of -0.02% per year over the entire survey period spanning across 65 years from 1956 till 2020 ( < 0.001). In psychiatry, a similar decline was observed, from around 4-4.5% in the late 1950s to just below 0.5% in the 2010s, in an extent of -0.1% per year ( < 0.001). However, a reverse trend was observed for psychoanalysis literature, which generally increased from 10-20% before the 1980s to 25-30% since the 2000s, in an extent of +0.2% per year ( < 0.001). Meanwhile, the annual percentage of CPs coming from psychology and psychiatry was decreasing by 0.4% per year ( < 0.001). Bibliometric data supported the notion that Freud's influence was on a decline in psychology and psychiatry fields.
西格蒙德·弗洛伊德偶尔会被认为过时了,他的作品与学术界不再相关。从科学网收集并分析了引用弗洛伊德作品的引用论文(CPs)。记录了CPs最常见的10个研究领域,并检索了各自文献主体的总量。我计算了引用弗洛伊德作品的各文献主体的年度百分比。另外,我计算了来自心理学和精神病学的引用的年度百分比。基于42571篇CPs的结果发现,心理学占引用弗洛伊德作品的一半以上。引用弗洛伊德作品的心理学论文百分比从20世纪50年代末的约3%逐渐下降到21世纪10年代的约1%,在1956年至2020年这65年的整个调查期内,每年下降幅度为-0.02%(<0.001)。在精神病学领域也观察到了类似的下降,从20世纪50年代末的约4%-4.5%下降到21世纪10年代略低于0.5%,每年下降幅度为-0.1%(<0.001)。然而,精神分析文献则呈现相反的趋势,总体上从20世纪80年代前的10%-20%增加到21世纪以来的25%-30%,每年增加幅度为+0.2%(<0.001)。与此同时,来自心理学和精神病学的CPs年度百分比每年下降0.4%(<0.001)。文献计量数据支持了弗洛伊德在心理学和精神病学领域的影响力正在下降这一观点。