Piña-Rey Alba, Ribeiro Helena, Fernández-González María, Abreu Ilda, Rodríguez-Rajo F Javier
Sciences Faculty of Ourense, Campus da Auga, University of Vigo, 32004 Ourense, Spain.
Earth Sciences Institute (ICT), Pole of the Faculty of Sciences, University of Porto, 4169-007 Porto, Portugal.
Plants (Basel). 2021 Mar 8;10(3):502. doi: 10.3390/plants10030502.
The aim of this study was to assess the thermal requirements of the most important grapevine varieties in northwestern Spain to better understand the impact of climate change on their phenology. Different phenological models (GDD, GDD Triangular and UniFORC) were tested and validated to predict budburst and flowering dates of grapevines at the variety level using phenological observations collected from Treixadura, Godello, Loureira and Albariño between 2008 and 2019. The same modeling framework was assessed to obtain the most suitable model for this region. The parametrization of the models was carried out with the Phenological Modeling Platform (PMP) platform by means of an iterative optimization process. Phenological data for all four varieties were used to determine the best-fitted parameters for each variety and model type that best predicted budburst and flowering dates. A model calibration phase was conducted using each variety dataset independently, where the intermediate-fitted parameters for each model formulation were freely-adjusted. Afterwards, the parameter set combination of the model providing the highest performance for each variety was externally validated with the dataset of the other three varieties, which allowed us to establish one overall unique model for budburst and flowering for all varieties. Finally, the performance of this model was compared with the attained one while considering all varieties in one dataset (12 years × 4 varieties giving a total number of observations of 48). For both phenological stages, the results showed no considerable differences between the GDD and Triangular GDD models. The best parameters selected were those provided by the Treixadura GDD model for budburst (day of the year (t) = 49 and base temperature (Tb) = 5) and those corresponding to the Godello model (t = 52 and Tb = 6) for flowering. The modeling approach employed allowed obtaining a global prediction model that can adequately predict budburst and flowering dates for all varieties.
本研究的目的是评估西班牙西北部最重要葡萄品种的热量需求,以便更好地了解气候变化对其物候的影响。使用2008年至2019年期间从特雷霞杜拉、戈德洛、洛雷拉和阿尔巴利诺收集的物候观测数据,对不同的物候模型(生长度日、三角形生长度日和统一强迫模型)进行了测试和验证,以预测品种层面葡萄树的萌芽和开花日期。评估了相同的建模框架,以获得该地区最合适的模型。通过迭代优化过程,使用物候建模平台(PMP)对模型进行参数化。所有四个品种的物候数据用于确定每个品种和模型类型的最佳拟合参数,这些参数能最好地预测萌芽和开花日期。使用每个品种的数据集独立进行模型校准阶段,在此阶段,对每个模型公式的中间拟合参数进行自由调整。之后,用其他三个品种的数据集对为每个品种提供最高性能的模型的参数集组合进行外部验证,这使我们能够为所有品种建立一个用于萌芽和开花的总体唯一模型。最后,将该模型的性能与在一个数据集中考虑所有品种时(12年×4个品种,总观测数为48)获得的模型性能进行比较。对于两个物候阶段,结果表明生长度日模型和三角形生长度日模型之间没有显著差异。所选的最佳参数是特雷霞杜拉生长度日模型用于萌芽的参数(一年中的天数(t)=49,基础温度(Tb)=5)以及戈德洛模型用于开花的参数(t = 52,Tb = 6)。所采用的建模方法能够获得一个全局预测模型,该模型可以充分预测所有品种的萌芽和开花日期。