Clancy Caitlin B, Heath Janae K, Nandiwada Deepa Rani, Aizenberg David, Kassutto Stacey
Division of Allergy, Pulmonary, and Critical Care Medicine and.
Center for Healthcare Improvement and Patient Safety and.
ATS Sch. 2020 Mar 9;1(2):161-169. doi: 10.34197/ats-scholar.2019-0011IN.
Ambulatory education is currently underemphasized in pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM) fellowship training. Existing clinic precepting models, originally developed for students and residents, do not meet the unique needs of fellow-level trainees. We aimed to develop and implement a novel fellow-led precepting model to improve ambulatory education for PCCM trainees. We performed a mixed-methods needs assessment, including surveys, focus groups, and direct observations, to explore perceptions of ambulatory training, define current precepting practices, and identify target areas for improvement. On the basis of these findings, we developed, implemented, and evaluated a novel model for PCCM outpatient precepting. A targeted needs assessment identified that current precepting practices did not meet fellows' needs for graduated autonomy, development of assessment and management skills, and self-directed learning. We developed and implemented a novel, learner-driven precepting model (Set the Stage, Tell the Story, Educational Goals, Preliminary Plan, Uncertainties, Plan Recap [STEP-UP]), designed to prioritize clinical reasoning skills and self-identification of learning goals. Implementation of the STEP-UP model improved perceptions of overall outpatient training and precepting. However, we faced several barriers to uptake of the new model, including increased cognitive burden of integrating a new process. A robust assessment of ambulatory education at a single PCCM fellowship program identified a need to align precepting processes with the unique goals of advanced trainees. We developed a learner-driven precepting model focused on development of clinical reasoning skills and self-directed educational objectives. Additional study is warranted to refine, adapt, and test the model in different setting.
目前,门诊教育在肺科与重症医学(PCCM)专科培训中未得到足够重视。现有的临床带教模式最初是为医学生和住院医师设计的,无法满足专科培训学员的独特需求。我们旨在开发并实施一种新型的由专科培训学员主导的带教模式,以改善PCCM学员的门诊教育。我们进行了一项混合方法需求评估,包括调查、焦点小组讨论和直接观察,以探究对门诊培训的看法,界定当前的带教实践,并确定改进的目标领域。基于这些发现,我们开发、实施并评估了一种新型的PCCM门诊带教模式。一项有针对性的需求评估表明,当前的带教实践无法满足学员对逐步获得自主权、培养评估与管理技能以及自主学习的需求。我们开发并实施了一种新型的、以学习者为驱动的带教模式(设定阶段、讲述病例、教育目标、初步计划、不确定因素、计划回顾[STEP - UP]),旨在优先培养临床推理技能和自我确定学习目标。STEP - UP模式的实施改善了对整体门诊培训和带教的看法。然而,我们在采用新模式时面临一些障碍,包括整合新流程带来的认知负担增加。对单一PCCM专科培训项目的门诊教育进行的全面评估表明,有必要使带教流程与高级学员的独特目标保持一致。我们开发了一种以学习者为驱动的带教模式,侧重于临床推理技能的培养和自主教育目标。有必要进行更多研究,以便在不同环境中完善、调整和测试该模式。