Cakmak Guner, Mantoglu Baris
Department of General Surgery, Sakarya Training and Research Hospital, Sakarya, TUR.
Cureus. 2021 Mar 24;13(3):e14085. doi: 10.7759/cureus.14085.
In our study, we aim to evaluate in terms of patients the quality and reliability of the most relevant and most-watched videos uploaded on YouTube about pancreatic cancer.
Before starting the study, YouTube search terms were determined by consensus by two General Surgeons. Then, on 10/10/2020, the terms such as "pancreatic cancer", "diagnosis of pancreatic cancer" and "treatment of pancreatic cancer" were entered separately in the search bar of YouTube, "relevance" was selected among the filtering options and the most viewed videos were listed. The videos were evaluated with the Global Quality Scale (GQS), the DISCERN scoring system (Quality Criteria for Consumer Health Information, http://www.discern.org.uk), and video power index.
Among the 50 videos analysed, 19 videos were uploaded by hospital channels, 17 videos by health channels, seven videos by patients, four videos by blog channels, and three videos by doctors. The mean GQS score of the first researcher was 3.24 ± 0.99 and the mean GQS score of the second researcher was 3.18 ± 0.88 with a significantly high agreement between them (r= 0.628). The mean DISCERN score of the first researcher was 3.48 ± 0.77 and the mean DISCERN score of the second researcher was 3.46 ± 1.09 with a significantly high agreement between them (r= 0.814).
In our study, the majority of the videos were found to be of moderate quality. Healthcare professionals should be encouraged to upload more videos with useful content. However, we think that the uploaded videos should definitely go through a professional peer-review process before they are published.
在我们的研究中,我们旨在从患者的角度评估上传到YouTube上关于胰腺癌的最相关且观看量最高的视频的质量和可靠性。
在研究开始前,由两位普通外科医生通过共识确定YouTube搜索词。然后,在2020年10月10日,“胰腺癌”“胰腺癌的诊断”和“胰腺癌的治疗”等词分别输入YouTube搜索栏,在筛选选项中选择“相关性”,并列出观看量最高的视频。使用全球质量量表(GQS)、DISCERN评分系统(消费者健康信息质量标准,http://www.discern.org.uk)和视频影响力指数对视频进行评估。
在分析的50个视频中,19个视频由医院频道上传,17个视频由健康频道上传,7个视频由患者上传,4个视频由博客频道上传,3个视频由医生上传。第一位研究人员的平均GQS评分为3.24±0.99,第二位研究人员的平均GQS评分为3.18±0.88,两人之间的一致性非常高(r = 0.628)。第一位研究人员的平均DISCERN评分为3.48±0.77,第二位研究人员的平均DISCERN评分为3.46±1.09,两人之间的一致性非常高(r = 0.814)。
在我们的研究中,发现大多数视频质量中等。应鼓励医疗保健专业人员上传更多有实用内容的视频。然而,我们认为上传的视频在发布前肯定要经过专业的同行评审过程。