Division of Intramural Population Health Research, Social and Behavioral Sciences Branch, Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, Bethesda, Maryland, United States of America.
Department of Nutrition and Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of Public Health and Health Sciences, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2021 May 13;16(5):e0251533. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0251533. eCollection 2021.
Maximizing data completion and study retention is essential in population research. This study examined the effect of remuneration schedule and data collection modality on data completion and retention in the Pregnancy Eating Attributes Study cohort. Participants (n = 458) completed online surveys and attended six in-person study visits. Initially, remuneration was a prespecified amount per visit, then was changed mid-study to be prorated based on the number of forms completed. Additionally, survey data collection modality was changed to in-person at the sixth study visit. In this secondary data analysis, there was no effect of remuneration schedule on withdrawal rates or time-to-withdrawal. Survey completion was significantly lower under prorated remuneration at the first visit but did not significantly differ at subsequent visits. The lump sum group had significantly greater odds of completely the first and second trimester dietary record (OR = 4.1, OR = 2.6, respectively) then the prorated group but were almost half as likely to complete the dietary record at the 6-month postpartum visit (OR = 0.5). Survey completion at sixth visit was significantly higher for in-person versus online completion (68.6% vs. 93.1%). Findings suggest that remuneration schedule and data collection modality can impact completion of self- reported assessments.
在人群研究中,最大限度地提高数据完成率和研究保留率至关重要。本研究考察了酬金方案和数据收集方式对妊娠饮食属性研究队列中数据完成率和保留率的影响。参与者(n=458)完成了在线调查并参加了六次面对面的研究访问。最初,酬金是按每次访问的预定金额支付的,然后在研究中途改为按完成的表格数量按比例支付。此外,在第六次研究访问时,调查数据收集方式改为面对面。在这项二次数据分析中,酬金方案对退出率或退出时间没有影响。按比例支付酬金时,第一次访问的调查完成率显著降低,但在随后的访问中没有显著差异。在第一次和第二次妊娠膳食记录中,整笔酬金组完全完成的可能性显著高于按比例酬金组(OR=4.1,OR=2.6),但在 6 个月产后访问中完成膳食记录的可能性几乎减半(OR=0.5)。面对面完成第六次访问的调查完成率显著高于在线完成(68.6%比 93.1%)。研究结果表明,酬金方案和数据收集方式可能会影响自我报告评估的完成情况。