Yang Yiyuan, Gao Riqiang, Tang Yucheng, Antic Sanja L, Deppen Steve, Huo Yuankai, Sandler Kim L, Massion Pierre P, Landman Bennett A
Computer Science, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA 37235.
Electrical Engineering, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA 37235.
Proc SPIE Int Soc Opt Eng. 2020;11313. doi: 10.1117/12.2548755. Epub 2020 Mar 10.
Deep learning has achieved many successes in medical imaging, including lung nodule segmentation and lung cancer prediction on computed tomography (CT). Recently, multi-task networks have shown to both offer additional estimation capabilities, and, perhaps more importantly, increased performance over single-task networks on a "main/primary" task. However, balancing the optimization criteria of multi-task networks across different tasks is an area of active exploration. Here, we extend a previously proposed 3D attention-based network with four additional multi-task subnetworks for the detection of lung cancer and four auxiliary tasks (diagnosis of asthma, chronic bronchitis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and emphysema). We introduce and evaluate a learning policy, Periodic Focusing Learning Policy (PFLP), that alternates the dominance of tasks throughout the training. To improve performance on the primary task, we propose an Internal-Transfer Weighting (ITW) strategy to suppress the loss functions on auxiliary tasks for the final stages of training. To evaluate this approach, we examined 3386 patients (single scan per patient) from the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) and de-identified data from the Vanderbilt Lung Screening Program, with a 2517/277/592 (scans) split for training, validation, and testing. Baseline networks include a single-task strategy and a multi-task strategy without adaptive weights (PFLP/ITW), while primary experiments are multi-task trials with either PFLP or ITW or both. On the test set for lung cancer prediction, the baseline single-task network achieved prediction AUC of 0.8080 and multi-task baseline failed to converge (AUC 0.6720). However, applying PFLP helped multi-task network clarify and achieved test set lung cancer prediction AUC of 0.8402. Furthermore, our ITW technique boosted the PFLP enabled multi-task network and achieved an AUC of 0.8462 (McNemar test, p < 0.01). In conclusion, adaptive consideration of multi-task learning weights is important, and PFLP and ITW are promising strategies.
深度学习在医学成像领域已取得诸多成功,包括在计算机断层扫描(CT)上进行肺结节分割和肺癌预测。最近,多任务网络已显示出既能提供额外的估计能力,而且或许更重要的是,在“主要/首要”任务上比单任务网络有更高的性能。然而,在不同任务间平衡多任务网络的优化标准仍是一个活跃的探索领域。在此,我们扩展了一个先前提出的基于3D注意力的网络,增加了四个额外的多任务子网用于肺癌检测以及四个辅助任务(哮喘、慢性支气管炎、慢性阻塞性肺疾病和肺气肿的诊断)。我们引入并评估了一种学习策略,即周期性聚焦学习策略(PFLP),该策略在整个训练过程中交替主导任务。为提高主要任务的性能,我们提出一种内部转移加权(ITW)策略,在训练的最后阶段抑制辅助任务的损失函数。为评估此方法,我们检查了来自国家肺癌筛查试验(NLST)的3386名患者(每位患者单次扫描)以及范德比尔特肺癌筛查项目的去识别数据,以2517/277/592(扫描)的比例划分为训练集、验证集和测试集。基线网络包括单任务策略和无自适应权重的多任务策略(PFLP/ITW),而主要实验是采用PFLP或ITW或两者的多任务试验。在肺癌预测的测试集上,基线单任务网络的预测AUC为0.8080,多任务基线未能收敛(AUC为0.6720)。然而,应用PFLP有助于多任务网络清晰化,并在测试集上实现了0.8402的肺癌预测AUC。此外,我们的ITW技术提升了启用PFLP的多任务网络,并实现了0.8462的AUC(McNemar检验,p < 0.01)。总之,对多任务学习权重进行自适应考虑很重要,PFLP和ITW是很有前景的策略。