Allaria Camille, Loubière Sandrine, Mosnier Emilie, Monfardini Elisa, Auquier Pascal, Tinland Aurelie
Aix Marseille University, School of Medicine - La Timone Medical Campus, EA 3279: CEReSS - Health Service Research and Quality of Life Center, Marseille, 13005, France.
LAMES - Laboratoire Méditerranéen de Sociologie, UMR 7305, MMSH - Maison Méditerranéenne des Sciences de L'Homme, Aix-en-Provence, 13094, France.
SSM Popul Health. 2021 Sep;15:100829. doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2021.100829. Epub 2021 May 28.
While social inequality is widely recognised as being a risk factor for COVID-19 infection or serious forms of the disease, many questions still remain concerning the perception of hazard and protective measures by the most vulnerable populations. This mixed-methods study aimed (1) to describe the self-perceived health and protective measures linked to COVID-19 of homeless people in one of the largest and poorest cities in France, and (2) to assess which skills and resources they used to address the COVID-19 pandemic. The quantitative survey addressed these questions among a sample of 995 homeless people living either on the streets, in homeless shelters or in squats/slums, whereas the qualitative survey was constructed from 14 homeless interviewees. Both data collections were carried out between June and July 2020. Results showed that COVID-19 infection was clearly perceived by homeless people as a risk, but the experience of being homeless placed this risk among several others. Different practices of protection were observed according to the type of living place. Lockdown of the general population severely impacted the survival systems of the populations furthest from housing, with alarming rates of people without access to water or food. 77% of homeless participants reported that they encountered significant financial difficulties. All interviewees were particularly attentive to their health, with awareness and even a familiarity with the risks of infectious diseases long before the pandemic. Using a capability framework, our study showed a predominant lack of external health-related resources for homeless people, while internal health-related resources were more developed than expected. None of the places and lifestyles studied was favourable to health: collective shelters due to a greater restriction of people's choices, slums and street life due to a greater lack of basic resources.
虽然社会不平等被广泛认为是感染新冠病毒或出现严重病症的一个风险因素,但关于最弱势群体对风险的认知以及防护措施仍存在许多问题。这项混合方法研究旨在:(1)描述法国最大且最贫困城市之一的无家可归者与新冠病毒相关的自我感知健康状况和防护措施;(2)评估他们应对新冠疫情所使用的技能和资源。定量调查针对995名生活在街头、收容所或棚户区/贫民窟的无家可归者样本提出了这些问题,而定性调查则基于14名无家可归者的访谈构建。两项数据收集工作均在2020年6月至7月期间进行。结果显示,无家可归者清楚地将新冠病毒感染视为一种风险,但无家可归的经历使这种风险与其他多种风险并存。根据居住场所类型观察到了不同的防护做法。普通人群的封锁对住房条件最差的人群的生存系统产生了严重影响,缺水或缺粮的人数比例令人担忧。77%的无家可归参与者报告称他们遇到了重大经济困难。所有受访者都特别关注自身健康,在疫情大流行之前很久就意识到甚至熟悉传染病风险。通过能力框架,我们的研究表明,无家可归者明显缺乏与健康相关的外部资源,而与健康相关的内部资源比预期更为发达。所研究的任何居住场所和生活方式都不利于健康:集体收容所由于人们的选择受到更大限制,贫民窟和街头生活则由于基本资源更加匮乏。