French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health & Safety (ANSES), 14 rue Pierre et Marie Curie, 94701, Maisons-Alfort, France.
European Environment Agency (EEA), Kongens Nytorv 6, 1050, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2021 Jul;236:113778. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2021.113778. Epub 2021 Jun 2.
The European Human Biomonitoring Initiative (HBM4EU) has established a European Union-wide human biomonitoring (HBM) programme to generate knowledge on human internal exposure to chemical pollutants and their potential health impacts in Europe, in order to support policy makers' efforts to ensure chemical safety and improve health in Europe. A prioritisation strategy was necessary to determine and meet the most important needs of both policy makers and risk assessors, as well as common national needs of participating countries and a broad range of stakeholders. This strategy consisted of three mains steps: 1) mapping of knowledge gaps identified by policy makers, 2) prioritisation of substances using a scoring system, and 3) generation of a list of priority substances reflective of the scoring, as well as of public policy priorities and available resources. For the first step, relevant ministries and agencies at EU and national levels, as well as members of the Stakeholder Forum each nominated up to 5 substances/substance groups of concern for policy-makers. These nominations were collated into a preliminary list of 48 substances/substance groups, which was subsequently shortened to a list of 23 after considering the total number of nominations each substance/substance group received and the nature of the nominating entities. For the second step, a panel of 11 experts in epidemiology, toxicology, exposure sciences, and occupational and environmental health scored each of the substances/substance groups using prioritisation criteria including hazardous properties, exposure characteristics, and societal concern. The scores were used to rank the 23 substances/substance groups. In addition, substances were categorised according to the level of current knowledge about their hazards, extent of human exposure (through the availability of HBM data), regulatory status and availability of analytical methods for biomarker measurement. Finally, in addition to the ranking and categorisation of the substances, the resources available for the project and the alignment with the policy priorities at European level were considered to produce a final priority list of 9 substances/substance groups for research activities and surveys within the framework of the HBM4EU project.
欧盟人类生物监测倡议 (HBM4EU) 建立了一个全欧盟范围的人类生物监测 (HBM) 计划,以生成有关欧洲人类内部接触化学污染物及其潜在健康影响的知识,以支持政策制定者努力确保欧洲的化学安全和改善健康。需要制定一项优先排序策略,以确定和满足政策制定者和风险评估人员的最重要需求,以及参与国家的共同国家需求和广泛的利益相关者的需求。该策略由三个主要步骤组成:1)确定政策制定者确定的知识差距,2)使用评分系统对物质进行优先排序,3)根据评分以及公共政策优先事项和可用资源生成优先物质清单。对于第一步,欧盟和国家各级的相关部委和机构以及利益相关者论坛的成员各自提名了最多 5 种供政策制定者关注的物质/物质组。这些提名被整理成一个初步的 48 种物质/物质组清单,随后在考虑到每种物质/物质组收到的提名总数和提名实体的性质后,将其缩短为 23 种物质/物质组清单。对于第二步,一个由流行病学、毒理学、暴露科学以及职业和环境卫生领域的 11 名专家组成的小组使用包括危险特性、暴露特征和社会关注在内的优先排序标准对每个物质/物质组进行评分。分数用于对 23 种物质/物质组进行排名。此外,根据对其危害的现有知识水平、人类暴露程度(通过 HBM 数据的可用性)、监管状况和生物标志物测量分析方法的可用性对物质进行分类。最后,除了对物质进行排名和分类外,还考虑了项目可用的资源以及与欧洲层面政策优先事项的一致性,以确定 HBM4EU 项目框架内研究活动和调查的 9 种物质/物质组的最终优先清单。