Conrozier Thierry, Raman Raghu, Chevalier Xavier, Henrotin Yves, Monfort Jordi, Diraçoglù Demirhan, Bard Hervé, Baron Dominique, Jerosch Jörg, Richette Pascal, Migliore Alberto
Department of Rheumatology, Hôpital Nord Franche-Comté, 100 route de Moval, CS 10499 Trévenans, Belfort, 90015, France.
Academic Department of Orthopaedics, Hull and East Yorkshire NHS Trust Castle Hill Hospital, Cottingham, UK.
Ther Adv Musculoskelet Dis. 2021 May 28;13:1759720X211018605. doi: 10.1177/1759720X211018605. eCollection 2021.
Viscosupplementation (VS) is a symptomatic treatment for knee and other joint osteoarthritis (OA). Despite a long history of use, conflicting opinions remain on the best clinical indications and the most appropriate patients to be treated with intra-articular hyaluronic acid (IA-HA), the optimal dosing regimen and the modalities of retreatment. A multidisciplinary committee of European experts on OA (EUROVISCO) was constituted to formulate recommendations, aimed at helping physicians in the decision-making and the optimal achievement of VS. Before each session members were tasked to collate an exhaustive literature review. Level of evidence and strength of recommendation were based on the level of agreement for each item according to the Delphi method. In 2015, a consensus position was proposed for 24 statements. Among those that obtained a consensual agreement, the working group stressed that VS is effective in mild/moderate knee OA but is not an alternative to surgery in advanced OA, and that dosing regimen must be supported by controlled trials. In 2018, two decision algorithms for the retreatment with IA-HA in knee OA were published. Among the key recommendations, the experts recommended to re-treat every year patients with high risk of OA progression, even if not symptomatic. In 2020, EUROVISCO published two sets of recommendations for the design of clinical trials on the disease-modifying effect of VS and for optimizing the results of VS. The working group underlined that an accurate analysis of radiological features and symptoms and a careful clinical examination may improve the chances of success of VS, as well as good technique of injection and the use of imaging guidance. Based on the exhaustive analysis of the literature and their own clinical experience, the EUROVISCO experts offer a wide range of recommendations intended to help practitioners, particularly in certain cases where the specific characteristics of the patients make the therapeutic decision difficult.
关节腔注射补充透明质酸(VS)是治疗膝关节及其他关节骨关节炎(OA)的一种对症治疗方法。尽管其应用历史悠久,但对于最佳临床适应症、最适合接受关节腔内注射透明质酸(IA-HA)治疗的患者、最佳给药方案以及再次治疗方式等问题,仍存在相互矛盾的观点。为此,欧洲骨关节炎专家多学科委员会(EUROVISCO)成立,旨在制定相关建议,以帮助医生进行决策并实现VS的最佳疗效。每次会议前,成员们的任务是整理详尽的文献综述。证据水平和推荐强度基于德尔菲法对每个项目的一致同意程度。2015年,针对24项声明提出了共识立场。在达成共识的声明中,工作组强调VS对轻/中度膝关节OA有效,但在晚期OA中并非手术的替代方法,且给药方案必须有对照试验支持。2018年,发表了两种膝关节OA中IA-HA再次治疗的决策算法。在关键建议中,专家们建议每年对有OA进展高风险的患者进行再次治疗,即使他们没有症状。2020年,EUROVISCO发表了两组关于VS疾病修饰作用临床试验设计和优化VS结果的建议。工作组强调,对放射学特征和症状进行准确分析以及仔细的临床检查,可能会提高VS成功的几率,同时还包括良好的注射技术和影像引导的使用。基于对文献的详尽分析和自身临床经验,EUROVISCO专家提供了广泛的建议,旨在帮助从业者,特别是在某些因患者特殊特征而使治疗决策困难的情况下。