Department of Rheumatology, Hôpital Nord Franche-Comté, Belfort, France.
Servei de Reumatologia, Hospital del Mar, Barcelona, Spain.
Cartilage. 2020 Jan;11(1):47-59. doi: 10.1177/1947603518783455. Epub 2018 Jun 21.
The 3 aims of the work were to identify population subgroups that can benefit the most from viscosupplementation (VS), to provide recommendations on injection techniques, and to discuss VS appropriateness in clinical situations that are commonplace in daily practice.
The task force members voted on their degree of agreement on 27 statements, 36 recommendations, and 22 clinical scenarios using a 9-point scale. The strength of agreement/appropriateness/recommendation (SOA/SOR) was classified as strong if the median agreement score was ≥8. The level of consensus (LOC) was also obtained.
Among the assumed predictors for VS failure, obesity, radiographic severity, large synovial fluid effusion, severe patellofemoral involvement, major malalignment, and gross joint instability received a large majority of agreements. The lateral mid-patellar approach was recommended for knee injection. Imaging guidance was unanimously recommended for hip and ankle. Agreement was achieved to strictly respect the dosing regimen proven by controlled trials. There was agreement for treating with VS patients with mild to moderate knee and hip OA, with normal weight or moderate overweight, insufficiently improved by first-line therapies, or who do not wish get oral treatment or who have contraindications to pain killers. The group considered the patient's wishes as a key element in therapeutic decision making.
Based on literature data and clinical experience, the EUROVISCO group proposed a set of recommendations for optimizing the results of VS, aimed to help practitioners, especially in some cases in which the patients' specificities make the therapeutic decision difficult.
这项工作的 3 个目标是确定最能从黏弹性补充治疗(VS)中获益的人群亚组,提供注射技术建议,并讨论在日常实践中常见的临床情况下 VS 的适宜性。
工作组成员对 27 个陈述、36 个建议和 22 个临床情况使用 9 分制对其同意程度进行了投票。如果中位数同意评分≥8,则将同意程度/适宜性/建议的强度(SOA/SOR)归类为强。还获得了共识水平(LOC)。
在假设的 VS 失败预测因素中,肥胖、影像学严重程度、大量滑膜液渗出、严重髌股关节受累、主要畸形和关节明显不稳定得到了绝大多数的同意。建议采用髌旁外侧入路进行膝关节注射。髋关节和踝关节注射时一致推荐影像学引导。严格遵守临床试验证明的剂量方案得到了一致同意。对于轻度至中度膝骨关节炎和髋关节骨关节炎、体重正常或中度超重、一线治疗效果不佳、不愿接受口服治疗或对止痛药有禁忌的患者,治疗时使用 VS 得到了一致同意。专家组认为患者的意愿是治疗决策的关键因素。
基于文献数据和临床经验,EUROVISCO 小组提出了一套优化 VS 结果的建议,旨在帮助从业者,尤其是在某些情况下,患者的具体情况使得治疗决策变得困难。