Roué Aurélie, Harf Aurélie, Benoit Laelia, Sibeoni Jordan, Moro Marie Rose
Maison des Adolescents-Maison de Solenn, Hôpital Cochin, APHP, Paris, France.
Faculty of Psychology, Medical School, PCPP, University of Paris, Boulogne Billancourt, France.
Front Psychiatry. 2021 Jun 10;12:624841. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2021.624841. eCollection 2021.
School refusal is an important public health concern in adolescent psychiatry increasing over the past several years (5% of child and adolescent psychiatry consultations in France). Multifamily therapy has developed over 30 years. Its efficacy is validated in adult, child and adolescent psychiatry, including for children at risk of school exclusion. In this study, we aimed to explore the adolescents and their parent's experience of a multifamily therapy treatment of school refusal with a qualitative method. This qualitative study is based on an Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis approach. We conducted 15 semi-structured interviews, participants were adolescents ( = 6) and their parents ( = 9) who experienced multifamily therapy in an adolescent department in Paris. Data analysis was performed independently by two researchers. For the six families, school was a source of suffering, system paralysis and social exclusion. Families reported painful emotions and separation anxiety. For teenagers, multifamily therapy increased self-confidence and allowed group experience. For parents, it gave support and relieved from feelings of stigmatization and guilt. Parents became more aware of their adolescent's suffering and their insight. They all considered that multifamily therapy improved intra-family communication and expression of emotion. Participants highlighted the benefits of intergenerational interactions, activities, group and guidance from therapists. Multifamily therapy uses therapeutic tools from both family therapy (joining, resonance, family competence, and metacommunication) and group therapy (use of media, identity device, and mirror reactions). Parents expect school solutions from multifamily therapy and question how psychiatric treatment can deal with school, school refusal being therefore understood as a social functioning disorder.
学校拒学是青少年精神病学中一个重要的公共卫生问题,在过去几年中呈上升趋势(在法国,儿童和青少年精神病学咨询中有5%涉及此问题)。多家庭治疗已经发展了30多年。其疗效在成人、儿童和青少年精神病学中得到了验证,包括对有被学校排斥风险的儿童。在本研究中,我们旨在采用定性方法探索青少年及其父母对多家庭治疗学校拒学的体验。这项定性研究基于解释现象学分析方法。我们进行了15次半结构化访谈,参与者是在巴黎一个青少年科室接受多家庭治疗的青少年(n = 6)及其父母(n = 9)。数据分析由两名研究人员独立进行。对于这六个家庭来说,学校是痛苦、系统瘫痪和社会排斥的根源。家庭报告了痛苦的情绪和分离焦虑。对于青少年来说,多家庭治疗增强了自信心并提供了团体体验。对于父母来说,它给予了支持,减轻了耻辱感和内疚感。父母更加意识到他们青少年的痛苦以及他们的洞察力。他们都认为多家庭治疗改善了家庭内部的沟通和情感表达。参与者强调了代际互动、活动、团体以及治疗师指导的益处。多家庭治疗使用了家庭治疗(加入、共鸣、家庭能力和元沟通)和团体治疗(媒体使用、身份装置和镜像反应)的治疗工具。父母期望多家庭治疗能解决学校相关问题,并质疑精神科治疗如何应对学校问题,因此学校拒学被理解为一种社会功能障碍。