Department of Human Capital Management, Cracow University of Economics, Krakow, Poland.
Department of Organization and Management Methods, Cracow University of Economics, Krakow, Poland.
Hum Resour Health. 2021 Jun 28;19(1):77. doi: 10.1186/s12960-021-00620-0.
Polish healthcare providers already struggle with a deficiency concerning human resources, especially with regard to doctors and nurses. Because of this, effective HRM interventions should be taken in order to attract and retain medical personnel. Employer branding is one such intervention because it not only results in improving the organization's reputation as an employer but also improving HRM practices. However, to create an effective employer branding strategy, a contextual approach should be taken. Because of this, the aim of the study is to assess the importance of various factors influencing medical personnel's perception of a hospital's attractiveness as an employer.
The study was performed among 285 hospitals in Poland assuming a confidence level of 0.95. In each hospital, five respondents took part in the survey. The first cohort of respondents named 'Directors' consisted of hospital directors or employees authorized by them, mostly HR specialists. The other four groups were: 'Hybrid Doctors Managers' (individuals who had the roles of both doctor and manager); 'Hybrid Nurses Managers' (having the roles of both manager and nurse); 'Physicians'; 'Nurses'. Due to the ordinal nature of the data, the chi-square test of independence was used and the V-Cramer coefficient was determined. To indicate significant discrepancies between the responses of the respondents' cohorts, the Kruskal-Wallis rank test was conducted.
Various groups of respondents perceive hospital attractiveness as an employer differently. While the opinions of medical personnel are more or less homogeneous, the cohort of employees responsible for HRM are less consistent with regard to their perception of hospital attractiveness. Additionally, 'Directors' highlight tangible factors determining hospital desirability. Moreover, their hierarchy of the top five factors influencing EB clearly exposes their quantitative orientation towards hospital performance management. Medical personnel hierarchies of the determinants expose qualitative orientation. Excluding country-dependent factors, such as regularity of remuneration payment, the professionals value such determinants as a nice work atmosphere, cooperation with colleagues (specialists), good working conditions and, most importantly, employment stability. The last determinant results from generational and gender tendencies (feminization), and yet it stands in contradiction with a tendency of flexible employment implemented in most developed countries due to a lack of medical personnel.
The results showed the importance of adapting employer branding strategies to the medical professional groups (doctors and nurses). This is because their perception of employers' attractiveness differ. In addition, elements of the profession genotypes play an important role in how the physicians and nurses value various factors creating the employers' attractiveness. The research also revealed the fact that top managers or HR specialists can wrongly identify the hospitals attractiveness since they are more quantitatively than qualitatively oriented. For this reason, they may implement inefficient EB strategies.
波兰的医疗保健提供者已经面临人力资源短缺的问题,尤其是医生和护士。因此,应该采取有效的人力资源管理干预措施,以吸引和留住医务人员。雇主品牌建设就是这样一种干预措施,因为它不仅可以提高组织作为雇主的声誉,还可以改善人力资源管理实践。然而,要创建有效的雇主品牌战略,应该采取基于背景的方法。因此,本研究的目的是评估影响医务人员对医院作为雇主吸引力的各种因素的重要性。
该研究在波兰的 285 家医院进行,置信水平为 0.95。在每家医院,有五名受访者参与了调查。第一组受访者被命名为“主任”,包括医院主任或他们授权的员工,主要是人力资源专家。其他四个群体是:“混合医生经理”(同时担任医生和经理角色的个人);“混合护士经理”(同时担任经理和护士角色的个人);“医生”;“护士”。由于数据的有序性质,使用了独立性卡方检验,并确定了 V-Cramer 系数。为了表明受访者群体的回答之间存在显著差异,进行了克鲁斯卡尔-沃利斯秩检验。
不同群体的受访者对医院作为雇主的吸引力有不同的看法。虽然医务人员的意见或多或少是一致的,但负责人力资源管理的员工群体在他们对医院吸引力的看法上则不太一致。此外,“主任”强调了决定医院吸引力的有形因素。此外,他们对影响雇主品牌建设的前五个因素的优先级清楚地暴露了他们对医院绩效管理的定量取向。医务人员对决定因素的优先级则暴露了他们的定性取向。除了薪酬支付的规律性等因国家而异的因素外,专业人员还重视良好的工作氛围、与同事(专家)的合作、良好的工作条件,最重要的是就业稳定性等决定因素。最后一个决定因素是由代际和性别趋势(女性化)导致的,但由于缺乏医务人员,它与大多数发达国家实施的灵活就业趋势相矛盾。
结果表明,根据医疗专业人员群体(医生和护士)来调整雇主品牌战略的重要性。这是因为他们对雇主吸引力的看法不同。此外,职业基因的要素在医生和护士如何重视创造雇主吸引力的各种因素方面起着重要作用。研究还揭示了这样一个事实,即高层管理人员或人力资源专家可能会错误地识别医院的吸引力,因为他们更注重数量而不是质量。因此,他们可能会实施效率低下的雇主品牌战略。