Hassn Ahmed, Gupta Ashish, Ramadan Mohamed
Princess of Wales Hospital, Bridgend, United Kingdom.
Ann Med Surg (Lond). 2021 Jun 11;67:102499. doi: 10.1016/j.amsu.2021.102499. eCollection 2021 Jul.
Oesophagogastric resections continue to be a major surgical challenge with high morbidity, this has led to a worldwide trend for centralisation of these complex surgeries. However, there is no clear agreement on what constitutes a high-volume centre, leading to worldwide disparity. We evaluate our experience of oesophagogastric resection in a small volume unit to seek other factors that influence patient outcome.
We analysed 173 consecutive oesophagogastric resection from 2010 to 2020. The primary outcome was 30-day mortality and secondary outcome included peri-operative morbidity, length of stay, lymph node harvest, R0 resection. Collected continuous data were compared using the Mann-Whitney test and categorical data using the chi-squared test and expressed as p value.
Of the 173 patients, 94 (54%) underwent hybrid minimal invasive esophagectomy (HIMO) and 79 (46%) underwent gastrectomy. 135 (78%) patients received Neoadjuvant therapy. The site of tumour was GOJ in 29%, distal stomach in 26% and distal oesophagus in 20%. Perioperative morbidity was observed in 18 (19%) after esophagectomy and 9 (11.4%) after gastrectomy. The median lymph node harvest was 18 (range 5-42) and 168 patients (97%) had longitudinal R0 resection. The most common complication was neurological seen in 3.6% followed by pulmonary complication and anastomotic leak seen in 5 patients (3%) each. The median in hospital stay was 6 days and the 30 day mortality was 2.9% with one year survival of 87%.
Small volume centres can produce comparable results. The outcomes depend on multifold parameters which include surgeon's experience in the field, ability to adhere to protocols and procedures and strong interpersonal relationship with individual patients.
食管胃切除术仍然是一项具有高发病率的重大外科挑战,这导致了这些复杂手术在全球范围内集中化的趋势。然而,对于什么构成高容量中心并没有明确的共识,导致全球范围内的差异。我们评估了我们在一个小容量单位进行食管胃切除术的经验,以寻找影响患者预后的其他因素。
我们分析了2010年至2020年连续进行的173例食管胃切除术。主要结局是30天死亡率,次要结局包括围手术期发病率、住院时间、淋巴结清扫数量、R0切除。使用Mann-Whitney检验比较收集的连续数据,使用卡方检验比较分类数据,并以p值表示。
在173例患者中,94例(54%)接受了混合微创食管切除术(HIMO),79例(46%)接受了胃切除术。135例(78%)患者接受了新辅助治疗。肿瘤部位为胃食管交界部的占29%,远端胃的占26%,远端食管的占20%。食管切除术后18例(19%)出现围手术期并发症,胃切除术后9例(11.4%)出现围手术期并发症。淋巴结清扫中位数为18个(范围5-42个),168例患者(97%)实现了纵向R0切除。最常见的并发症是神经系统并发症,发生率为3.6%,其次是肺部并发症和吻合口漏,各有5例患者(3%)发生。住院中位时间为6天,30天死亡率为2.9%,一年生存率为87%。
小容量中心可以产生可比的结果。结局取决于多个参数,包括外科医生在该领域的经验、遵守方案和程序的能力以及与个体患者的良好人际关系。