Department of General Surgery, Complexo Hospitalario de Ourense, 32005 Ourense, Spain.
Department of Preventive Medicine and Public Health, University of Granada, 18016 Granada, Spain.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Jun 13;18(12):6411. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18126411.
Breast cancer (BC) management care requires an increment in quality. An initiative to improve the BC quality care is registered, and quality indicators (QIs) are studied. We appraised the appearance of QIs and their standards systematically in Spain. A prospective systematic search (Prospero no: CRD42021228867) for clinical pathways and integrated breast cancer care processes was conducted through databases and the World Wide Web in February 2021. Duplicate data extraction was performed with 98% reviewer agreement. Seventy-four QIs (QI per document mean: 11; standard deviation: 10.59) were found in 15 documents. The Catalonian document had the highest number of QIs ( = 30). No QI appeared in all the documents. There were 9/74 QIs covering structure (12.16%), 53/74 covering process (71.62%), and 12/74 covering outcome (16.22%). A total of 22/66 (33.33%) process and outcome QIs did not set a minimum standard of care. QIs related to primary care, patient satisfaction, and shared decision making were deficient. Most of the documents established a BC QI standard for compliance, but the high variability hinders the comparison of outcomes. Establishing a consensus-based set of QIs needs urgent attention.
乳腺癌(BC)管理护理需要提高质量。一项旨在提高 BC 质量护理的举措已经注册,并且正在研究质量指标(QIs)。我们在西班牙系统地评估了 QIs 的出现及其标准。2021 年 2 月,通过数据库和万维网对临床路径和综合乳腺癌护理流程进行了前瞻性系统搜索(Prospéro 编号:CRD42021228867)。采用 98%的审核员协议进行重复数据提取。在 15 份文件中发现了 74 个 QIs(每份文件的 QI 平均值:11;标准差:10.59)。加泰罗尼亚文件的 QI 数量最多(=30)。没有 QI 出现在所有的文件中。有 9/74 个 QIs 涵盖结构(12.16%),53/74 个 QIs 涵盖过程(71.62%),12/74 个 QIs 涵盖结果(16.22%)。共有 22/66(33.33%)的过程和结果 QIs 未设定最低护理标准。与初级保健、患者满意度和共同决策相关的 QIs 存在不足。大多数文件都为遵守规定制定了 BC QI 标准,但高变异性阻碍了结果的比较。建立基于共识的 QI 集需要紧急关注。