Department of Development Economics, Research Group on Economics and Management of Innovation, Autonomous University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
Department of Quantitative Methods in Economics, University of Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Las Palmas, Spain.
Int J Equity Health. 2021 Jul 6;20(1):156. doi: 10.1186/s12939-021-01438-x.
We analyzed two questions. First, the effectiveness of public Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) in Spain compared with private ones, measured by the time since initiating ART treatment until achieving pregnancy, accounting for age and socioeconomic factors. Second, socioeconomic determinants of access to ART, referring primarily to financial means derived by employment, income, and wealth.
We applied statistical models on data extracted from the national Spanish Fertility Survey from 2018. The first topic was analyzed by competing risk survival analysis conducted on a sample of 667 women who initiate ART treatment since 2000. The second, by a Bivariate Probit model conducted on a sample of 672 women older than 41 years who required ART services.
The first analysis raised that throughout the treatment, patients treated exclusively in private clinics had on average a higher cumulative incidence of becoming pregnant compared with patients who approached public clinics. The second analysis raised that both higher household equivalent income and higher education increase the likelihood of accessing ART in a private clinic and decrease the tendency of accessing public clinics or failing to access any service. Moreover, being single decreases the likelihood of accessing public clinics or ART services in general.
Long waiting periods could be the main reason for the lower incidence of getting pregnant in public healthcare, explaining why patients choose private over public care. We develop a broader discussion over the extent of Spanish public funding of ART, the unequal medical outcome, and potential options for optimization.
我们分析了两个问题。首先,通过比较自开始接受辅助生殖技术(ART)治疗到怀孕的时间,评估西班牙公共辅助生殖技术与私人辅助生殖技术的有效性,同时考虑年龄和社会经济因素。其次,研究辅助生殖技术获得途径的社会经济决定因素,主要指就业、收入和财富带来的经济手段。
我们应用统计模型对 2018 年全国西班牙生育调查的数据进行了分析。第一个主题通过对 2000 年以来接受 ART 治疗的 667 名女性进行竞争风险生存分析进行了分析。第二个主题通过对 672 名年龄大于 41 岁需要 ART 服务的女性进行双变量概率模型进行了分析。
第一项分析表明,在整个治疗过程中,在私人诊所接受治疗的患者的平均累积怀孕率明显高于在公共诊所接受治疗的患者。第二项分析表明,家庭等效收入越高和教育程度越高,在私人诊所获得 ART 的可能性就越大,而在公共诊所获得服务或无法获得任何服务的可能性就越小。此外,单身会降低在公共诊所或一般公共医疗服务中获得服务的可能性。
较长的等待时间可能是公共医疗保健中怀孕率较低的主要原因,这解释了为什么患者选择私人医疗而不是公共医疗。我们对西班牙公共资助 ART 的程度、不平等的医疗结果以及优化的潜在选择进行了更广泛的讨论。