Hindley Kristen, Fenton Clare, McIntosh Jennifer
University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Leeds and York Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Mill Lodge, 520 Huntington Rd, York, YO32 9QA, UK.
J Eat Disord. 2021 Jul 22;9(1):90. doi: 10.1186/s40337-021-00445-1.
Adolescents with severe restrictive eating disorders often require enteral feeding to provide lifesaving treatment. Nasogastric feeding (NG) is a method of enteral nutrition often used in inpatient settings to treat medical instability, to supplement poor oral intake or to increase nutritional intake. This systematic review sets out to describe current practice of NG in young people with eating disorders.
A systematic review following PRISMA guidelines was conducted by searching AMED, EMBASE and MEDLINE databases from 2000 to 2020. Inclusion terms were: enteral feeding by nasogastric tube, under 18 years, eating disorders, and primary research. Exclusion terms: psychiatric disorders other than eating disorders; non-primary research; no outcomes specific to NG feeding and participants over 18 years. Titles and abstracts were screened by all authors before reviewing full length articles. Quality assessment, including risk of bias, was conducted by all authors.
Twenty-nine studies met the full criteria. 86% of studies were deemed high or medium risk of bias due to the type of study: 34.4% retrospective cohort and 10.3% RCT; 17.2% were qualitative. Studies identified 1) a wide range of refeeding regimes depending on country, settings, and the reason for initiation; 2) standard practice is to introduce Nasogastric feeds (NG) if medically unstable or oral intake alone is inadequate; 3) NG may enable greater initial weight gain due to increased caloric intake; 4) there are 3 main types of feeding regime: continuous, nocturnal and bolus; 5) complications included nasal irritation, epistaxis, electrolyte disturbance, distress and tube removal; 6) where NG is routinely implemented to increase total calorie intake, length of stay in hospital may be reduced; however where NG is implemented in correlation to severity of symptoms, it may be increased; 7) both medical and psychiatric wards most commonly report using NG in addition to oral intake.
NG feeding is a safe and efficacious method of increasing total calorie intake by either supplementing oral intake or continuously. There are currently no direct comparisons between continuous, nocturnal or bolus regimes, which may be used to direct future treatment for YP with ED.
患有严重限制性饮食失调的青少年通常需要肠内喂养以提供挽救生命的治疗。鼻胃管喂养(NG)是一种肠内营养方法,常用于住院环境中治疗医疗不稳定状况、补充经口摄入不足或增加营养摄入。本系统评价旨在描述饮食失调青少年中鼻胃管喂养的当前实践情况。
按照PRISMA指南进行系统评价,检索2000年至2020年期间的AMED、EMBASE和MEDLINE数据库。纳入标准为:鼻胃管肠内喂养、18岁以下、饮食失调以及原始研究。排除标准为:除饮食失调以外的精神疾病;非原始研究;无鼻胃管喂养特定结局以及18岁以上参与者。在审阅全文之前,所有作者先筛选标题和摘要。所有作者进行质量评估,包括偏倚风险评估。
29项研究符合全部标准。由于研究类型,86%的研究被认为存在高或中度偏倚风险:34.4%为回顾性队列研究,10.3%为随机对照试验;17.2%为定性研究。研究发现:1)根据国家、环境和开始喂养的原因,存在广泛的再喂养方案;2)标准做法是在医疗不稳定或仅经口摄入不足时开始鼻胃管喂养(NG);3)由于热量摄入增加,鼻胃管喂养可能使初始体重增加更多;4)主要有三种喂养方式:持续喂养、夜间喂养和推注喂养;5)并发症包括鼻刺激、鼻出血、电解质紊乱、不适和拔管;6)常规采用鼻胃管喂养以增加总热量摄入时,住院时间可能缩短;然而,根据症状严重程度采用鼻胃管喂养时,住院时间可能延长;7)内科和精神科病房最常报告除经口摄入外还使用鼻胃管喂养。
鼻胃管喂养是一种安全有效的方法,可通过补充经口摄入或持续喂养来增加总热量摄入。目前,持续喂养、夜间喂养或推注喂养方式之间尚无直接比较,这可能用于指导未来对患有饮食失调的青少年的治疗。